1,
'price' => $product->get_price(),
) );
if ( function_exists( 'wc_get_price_including_tax' ) ) { // WC 3.0+
$price = wc_get_price_including_tax( $product, $args );
} else { // WC < 3.0
$price = $product->get_price_including_tax( $args['qty'], $args['price'] );
}
return $price;
}
/**
* For a given product, and optionally price/qty, work out the sign-up fee with tax excluded, based on store settings.
*
* @since 1.0.0 - Migrated from WooCommerce Subscriptions v2.2.0
* @param WC_Product $product
* @param array $args
* @return float
*/
function wcs_get_price_excluding_tax( $product, $args = array() ) {
$args = wp_parse_args( $args, array(
'qty' => 1,
'price' => $product->get_price(),
) );
if ( function_exists( 'wc_get_price_excluding_tax' ) ) { // WC 3.0+
$price = wc_get_price_excluding_tax( $product, $args );
} else { // WC < 3.0
$price = $product->get_price_excluding_tax( $args['qty'], $args['price'] );
}
return $price;
}
/**
* Returns a 'from' prefix if you want to show where prices start at.
*
* @since 1.0.0 - Migrated from WooCommerce Subscriptions v2.2.0
* @return string
*/
function wcs_get_price_html_from_text( $product = '' ) {
if ( function_exists( 'wc_get_price_html_from_text' ) ) { // WC 3.0+
$price_html_from_text = wc_get_price_html_from_text();
} else { // WC < 3.0
$price_html_from_text = $product->get_price_html_from_text();
}
return $price_html_from_text;
}
/**
* Get an array of the prices, used to help determine min/max values.
*
* @since 1.0.0 - Migrated from WooCommerce Subscriptions v2.2.0
*/
function wcs_get_variation_prices( $variation, $variable_product ) {
return array(
'price' => apply_filters( 'woocommerce_variation_prices_price', WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_price( $variation ), $variation, $variable_product ),
'regular_price' => apply_filters( 'woocommerce_variation_prices_regular_price', WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_regular_price( $variation, 'edit' ), $variation, $variable_product ),
'sale_price' => apply_filters( 'woocommerce_variation_prices_sale_price', WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_sale_price( $variation, 'edit' ), $variation, $variable_product ),
'sign_up_fee' => apply_filters( 'woocommerce_variation_prices_sign_up_fee', WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_sign_up_fee( $variation ), $variation, $variable_product ),
);
}
/**
* Get an array of the minimum and maximum priced variations based on subscription billing terms.
*
* @param array $child_variation_ids the IDs of product variation children ids
* @return array Array containing the min and max variation prices and billing data
* @since 1.0.0 - Migrated from WooCommerce Subscriptions v2.2.0
*/
function wcs_get_min_max_variation_data( $variable_product, $child_variation_ids = array() ) {
if ( empty( $child_variation_ids ) ) {
$child_variation_ids = is_callable( array( $variable_product, 'get_visible_children' ) ) ? $variable_product->get_visible_children() : $variable_product->get_children( true );
}
$variations_data = array();
foreach ( $child_variation_ids as $variation_id ) {
if ( $variation = wc_get_product( $variation_id ) ) {
$prices = wcs_get_variation_prices( $variation, $variable_product );
foreach ( $prices as $price_key => $amount ) {
if ( '' !== $amount ) {
if ( 'incl' === get_option( 'woocommerce_tax_display_shop' ) ) {
$prices[ $price_key ] = wcs_get_price_including_tax( $variable_product, array( 'price' => $amount ) );
} else {
$prices[ $price_key ] = wcs_get_price_excluding_tax( $variable_product, array( 'price' => $amount ) );
}
}
}
$variations_data[ $variation_id ] = array(
'price' => $prices['price'],
'regular_price' => $prices['regular_price'],
'sale_price' => $prices['sale_price'],
'subscription' => array(
'sign_up_fee' => $prices['sign_up_fee'],
'period' => WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_period( $variation ),
'interval' => WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_interval( $variation ),
'trial_length' => WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_trial_length( $variation ),
'trial_period' => WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_trial_period( $variation ),
'length' => WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_length( $variation ),
),
);
}
}
return wcs_calculate_min_max_variations( $variations_data );
}
/**
* Determine the minimum and maximum values for a set of structured subscription
* price data in a form created by @see wcs_get_min_max_variation_data()
*
* @param array $variations_data the IDs of product variation children ids
* @return array
* @since 1.0.0 - Migrated from WooCommerce Subscriptions v2.2.0
*/
function wcs_calculate_min_max_variations( $variations_data ) {
$lowest_initial_amount = $highest_initial_amount = $lowest_price = $highest_price = '';
$shortest_initial_period = $longest_initial_period = $shortest_trial_period = $longest_trial_period = $shortest_trial_length = $longest_trial_length = '';
$longest_initial_interval = $shortest_initial_interval = $variable_subscription_period = $variable_subscription_period_interval = '';
$lowest_regular_price = $highest_regular_price = $lowest_sale_price = $highest_sale_price = $max_subscription_period = $max_subscription_period_interval = '';
$variable_subscription_sign_up_fee = $variable_subscription_trial_period = $variable_subscription_trial_length = $variable_subscription_length = $variable_subscription_sign_up_fee = $variable_subscription_trial_period = $variable_subscription_trial_length = $variable_subscription_length = '';
$min_variation_id = $max_variation_id = null;
$variations_data_prices_list = array();
$variations_data_sign_up_fees_list = array();
$variations_data_periods_list = array();
$variations_data_intervals_list = array();
$variations_data_trial_lengths_list = array();
$variations_data_trial_periods_list = array();
$variations_data_lengths_list = array();
foreach ( $variations_data as $variation_id => $variation_data ) {
$is_max = $is_min = false;
if ( '' === $variation_data['price'] && empty( $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'] ) ) {
continue;
}
$variations_data_prices_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_prices_list, array( $variation_data['price'] ) ) );
$variations_data_sign_up_fees_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_sign_up_fees_list, array( empty( $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'] ) ? 0 : $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'] ) ) );
$variations_data_periods_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_periods_list, array( $variation_data['subscription']['period'] ) ) );
$variations_data_intervals_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_intervals_list, array( $variation_data['subscription']['interval'] ) ) );
$variations_data_trial_lengths_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_trial_lengths_list, array( empty( $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] ) ? 0 : $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] ) ) );
$variations_data_trial_periods_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_trial_periods_list, array( $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) ) );
$variations_data_lengths_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_lengths_list, array( $variation_data['subscription']['length'] ) ) );
$has_free_trial = '' !== $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] && $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] > 0;
// Determine some recurring price flags
$is_lowest_price = $variation_data['price'] < $lowest_price || '' === $lowest_price;
$is_longest_period = wcs_get_longest_period( $variable_subscription_period, $variation_data['subscription']['period'] ) === $variation_data['subscription']['period'];
$is_longest_interval = $variation_data['subscription']['interval'] >= $variable_subscription_period_interval || '' === $variable_subscription_period_interval;
// Find the amount the subscriber will have to pay up-front
if ( $has_free_trial ) {
$initial_amount = $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'];
$initial_period = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'];
$initial_interval = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'];
} else {
$initial_amount = (float) $variation_data['price'] + (float) $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'];
$initial_period = $variation_data['subscription']['period'];
$initial_interval = $variation_data['subscription']['interval'];
}
// We have a free trial & no sign-up fee, so need to choose the longest free trial (and maybe the shortest)
if ( $has_free_trial && 0 == $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'] ) {
// First variation
if ( '' === $longest_trial_period ) {
$is_min = true;
// If two variations have the same free trial, choose the variation with the lowest recurring price for the longest period
} elseif ( $variable_subscription_trial_period === $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] && $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] === $variable_subscription_trial_length ) {
// If the variation has the lowest recurring price, it's the cheapest
if ( $is_lowest_price ) {
$is_min = true;
// When current variation's free trial is the same as the lowest, it's the cheaper if it has a longer billing schedule
} elseif ( $variation_data['price'] === $lowest_price ) {
if ( $is_longest_period && $is_longest_interval ) {
$is_min = true;
// Longest with a new billing period
} elseif ( $is_longest_period && $variation_data['subscription']['period'] !== $variable_subscription_trial_period ) {
$is_min = true;
}
}
// Otherwise the cheapest variation is the one with the longer trial
} elseif ( $variable_subscription_trial_period === $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) {
$is_min = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] > $variable_subscription_trial_length;
// Otherwise just a longer trial period (that isn't equal to the longest period)
} elseif ( wcs_get_longest_period( $longest_trial_period, $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) === $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) {
$is_min = true;
}
if ( $is_min ) {
$longest_trial_period = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'];
$longest_trial_length = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'];
}
// If the current cheapest variation is also free, then the shortest trial period is the most expensive
if ( 0 == $lowest_price || '' === $lowest_price ) {
if ( '' === $shortest_trial_period ) {
$is_max = true;
// Need to check trial length
} elseif ( $shortest_trial_period === $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) {
$is_max = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] < $shortest_trial_length;
// Need to find shortest period
} elseif ( wcs_get_shortest_period( $shortest_trial_period, $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) === $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) {
$is_max = true;
}
if ( $is_max ) {
$shortest_trial_period = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'];
$shortest_trial_length = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'];
}
}
} else {
$longest_initial_period = wcs_get_longest_period( $longest_initial_period, $initial_period );
$shortest_initial_period = wcs_get_shortest_period( $shortest_initial_period, $initial_period );
$is_lowest_initial_amount = $initial_amount < $lowest_initial_amount || '' === $lowest_initial_amount;
$is_longest_initial_period = $initial_period === $longest_initial_period;
$is_longest_initial_interval = $initial_interval >= $longest_initial_interval || '' === $longest_initial_interval;
$is_highest_initial = $initial_amount > $highest_initial_amount || '' === $highest_initial_amount;
$is_shortest_period = $initial_period === $shortest_initial_period || '' === $shortest_initial_period;
$is_shortest_interval = $initial_interval < $shortest_initial_interval || '' === $shortest_initial_interval;
// If we're not dealing with the lowest initial access amount, then ignore this variation
if ( ! $is_lowest_initial_amount && $initial_amount !== $lowest_initial_amount ) {
continue;
}
// If the variation has the lowest price, it's the cheapest
if ( $is_lowest_initial_amount ) {
$is_min = true;
// When current variation's price is the same as the lowest, it's the cheapest only if it has a longer billing schedule
} elseif ( $initial_amount === $lowest_initial_amount ) {
// We need to check the recurring schedule when the sign-up fee & free trial periods are equal
if ( $has_free_trial && $initial_period == $longest_initial_period && $initial_interval == $longest_initial_interval ) {
// If the variation has the lowest recurring price, it's the cheapest
if ( $is_lowest_price ) {
$is_min = true;
// When current variation's price is the same as the lowest, it's the cheapest only if it has a longer billing schedule
} elseif ( $variation_data['price'] === $lowest_price ) {
if ( $is_longest_period && $is_longest_interval ) {
$is_min = true;
// Longest with a new billing period
} elseif ( $is_longest_period && $variation_data['subscription']['period'] !== $variable_subscription_period ) {
$is_min = true;
}
}
// Longest initial term is the cheapest
} elseif ( $is_longest_initial_period && $is_longest_initial_interval ) {
$is_min = true;
// Longest with a new billing period
} elseif ( $is_longest_initial_period && $initial_period !== $variable_subscription_period ) {
$is_min = true;
}
}
// If we have the highest price for the shortest period, we might have the maximum variation
if ( $is_highest_initial && $is_shortest_period && $is_shortest_interval ) {
$is_max = true;
// But only if its for the shortest billing period
} elseif ( $variation_data['price'] === $highest_price ) {
if ( $is_shortest_period && $is_shortest_interval ) {
$is_max = true;
} elseif ( $is_shortest_period ) {
$is_max = true;
}
}
}
// If it's the min subscription terms
if ( $is_min ) {
$min_variation_id = $variation_id;
$lowest_price = $variation_data['price'];
$lowest_regular_price = $variation_data['regular_price'];
$lowest_sale_price = $variation_data['sale_price'];
$lowest_regular_price = ( '' === $lowest_regular_price ) ? 0 : $lowest_regular_price;
$lowest_sale_price = ( '' === $lowest_sale_price ) ? 0 : $lowest_sale_price;
$lowest_initial_amount = $initial_amount;
$longest_initial_period = $initial_period;
$longest_initial_interval = $initial_interval;
$variable_subscription_sign_up_fee = $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'];
$variable_subscription_period = $variation_data['subscription']['period'];
$variable_subscription_period_interval = $variation_data['subscription']['interval'];
$variable_subscription_trial_length = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'];
$variable_subscription_trial_period = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'];
$variable_subscription_length = $variation_data['subscription']['length'];
}
if ( $is_max ) {
$max_variation_id = $variation_id;
$highest_price = $variation_data['price'];
$highest_regular_price = $variation_data['regular_price'];
$highest_sale_price = $variation_data['sale_price'];
$highest_initial_amount = $initial_amount;
$highest_regular_price = ( '' === $highest_regular_price ) ? 0 : $highest_regular_price;
$highest_sale_price = ( '' === $highest_sale_price ) ? 0 : $highest_sale_price;
$max_subscription_period = $variation_data['subscription']['period'];
$max_subscription_period_interval = $variation_data['subscription']['interval'];
}
}
if ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_prices_list ) ) > 1 ) {
$subscription_details_identical = false;
} elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_sign_up_fees_list ) ) > 1 ) {
$subscription_details_identical = false;
} elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_periods_list ) ) > 1 ) {
$subscription_details_identical = false;
} elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_intervals_list ) ) > 1 ) {
$subscription_details_identical = false;
} elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_trial_lengths_list ) ) > 1 ) {
$subscription_details_identical = false;
} elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_trial_periods_list ) ) > 1 ) {
$subscription_details_identical = false;
} elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_lengths_list ) ) > 1 ) {
$subscription_details_identical = false;
} else {
$subscription_details_identical = true;
}
return array(
'min' => array(
'variation_id' => $min_variation_id,
'price' => $lowest_price,
'regular_price' => $lowest_regular_price,
'sale_price' => $lowest_sale_price,
'period' => $variable_subscription_period,
'interval' => $variable_subscription_period_interval,
),
'max' => array(
'variation_id' => $max_variation_id,
'price' => $highest_price,
'regular_price' => $highest_regular_price,
'sale_price' => $highest_sale_price,
'period' => $max_subscription_period,
'interval' => $max_subscription_period_interval,
),
'subscription' => array(
'signup-fee' => $variable_subscription_sign_up_fee,
'trial_period' => $variable_subscription_trial_period,
'trial_length' => $variable_subscription_trial_length,
'length' => $variable_subscription_length,
),
'identical' => $subscription_details_identical,
);
}
/**
* Generates a key for grouping subscription products with the same billing schedule.
*
* Used in a frontend cart and checkout context to group items by a recurring cart key for use in generating recurring carts.
* Used by the orders/
HEADLINES INVESTIGATION: “We’ll Never Regain Public Trust” — Inside the City’s Tax-Rate Cover-Up is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>When Odessan Kris Crow stood before the Odessa City Council on September 17, 2025, he wasn’t just voicing a concern — he had already filed a formal complaint with the Texas Attorney General’s Office, asserting that the city was in violation of Senate Bill 1851. That new state law prevents cities from adopting a tax rate above the “no-new-revenue” rate if their annual audit and financial statement have not been timely filed.
From the dais, city leaders pushed back hard. Mayor Cal Hendrick and Interim City Attorney Keith Stretcher, citing “over 100 years of combined legal experience,” publicly assured citizens that SB 1851 did not apply to Odessa.
But Crow’s complaint had already set a process in motion—one that would soon expose just how deeply flawed the city’s internal numbers, procedures, and leadership had become.
Just nine days later, on September 26, 2025, Councilman Craig Stoker sent an email to the Mayor, City Manager David Vela, City Attorney Stretcher, and Assistant City Manager (now Interim City Manager) Aaron Smith. The subject line: “Re: Fixing the Tax Levy for the City of Odessa, Texas.”
Stoker’s email is remarkable — both for its bluntness and for what it reveals about the breakdown inside City Hall.
“I tried to call out the inaccuracy in our numbers and subsequent marketing,” Stoker wrote. “I mentioned that I did not like the use of that number at the budget workshop… but by that point I had been yelled at enough and demeaned by another council member that I mostly kept my mouth shut.”
He went on to blame both the Finance and Media Relations Departments for publishing and promoting false tax-rate data:
“As I expressed to you earlier this is a failure on the part of not only finance but also marketing. There are inaccuracies and conflicts all over the website regarding the budget and the data. All of them should know better.”
“Just like the mess with billing and collections, I am angry that we walk out with egg on our face and take the blame, but we don’t even have the ability to take any action to reassure the public that incompetent staff have been dealt with. We will never be able to rebuild any kind of public trust when we can’t even trust the staff ourselves.”
That single line — “We will never be able to rebuild any kind of public trust” — would prove prophetic.
Despite his frustration, Stoker concluded by saying he would still vote for the budget and the flawed tax rate “to avoid punishing the city” but vowed that “next year I will expect that we have a competent staff member or third-party budget manager. I will not suffer through this ridiculousness again.”
Just hours earlier that same evening, Mayor Hendrick had circulated his own message to the council — one that now raises serious Open Meetings Act concerns.
“You are each BCC’ed to avoid a violation of the Open Meetings Act,” Hendrick began, before adding: “I have talked to each of you individually this afternoon to explain the problems with the proposed tax rate and the fact that the effect of the proposed tax rate is much greater than what we understood.”
The Mayor went on to acknowledge that “we relied on inaccurate data” to communicate the new tax rate to the public — data used on the city’s website, social media, and in conversations with the press and staff.
He then described a decision point that, by his own words, appeared to have already been reached:
“We either do nothing and allow the new tax rate to become effective October 1, 2025, or we can meet next Friday and agree to a no-new-[revenue sic] tax rate… It is my understanding that Council members desire an opportunity to readdress the tax levy issue next week.”
Finally, Hendrick instructed City Manager Vela:
“Please get with the City Secretary and post a notice for a meeting for next Friday, October 3rd, at 11:00 AM… and a second notice for 11:30 AM.”
But those meetings were never posted — and never held.
A review of the city’s official agenda center confirms that no special meetings were scheduled for October 3, 2025.
No notices.
No minutes.
No explanation.
Instead, the city quietly proceeded with adopting the flawed tax rate — the same one both the mayor and Stoker had acknowledged internally was based on inaccurate data.
In doing so, they effectively hid the problem from the public.
No correction was issued.
No statement was made.
No effort was taken to fix what both the mayor and a sitting councilman knew to be wrong.
The events of late September 2025 fit a now-familiar pattern at Odessa City Hall:
Even after the Texas Attorney General opened an investigation, city officials publicly maintained that they had acted properly. That narrative unraveled, however, during a later press conference, when Mayor Cal Hendrick told reporters that the Council had decided in executive session to send a letter to Attorney General Ken Paxton stating that the city would not raise the 2025–26 tax rate above the no-new-revenue rate.
That admission is problematic on two fronts. First, it directly contradicts the public record — video of the meeting shows the Council reconvening from executive session and announcing that no action had been taken. Second, it appears to confirm a violation of the Texas Open Meetings Act, which prohibits taking or agreeing upon official action in closed session.
Hendrick further acknowledged that, amid the controversy, city officials had also found some problems with the way tax rates had been calculated in prior years, reinforcing the pattern of internal errors and after-the-fact disclosure that has plagued this administration.
That contradiction — between public denial and private admission — lies at the heart of Odessa’s credibility crisis.
Councilman Stoker’s words now serve as both confession and epitaph for the city’s handling of this affair:
“We will never be able to rebuild any kind of public trust when we can’t even trust the staff ourselves.”
He was right. The cover-up didn’t just destroy confidence in the city’s numbers — it shattered confidence in its leaders.
Crow did his duty by invoking state law and alerting the Attorney General.
Stoker did his duty by documenting the truth in writing but failed the public trust by not bringing his very valid concerns public.
The mayor and council clearly failed in their duty — to correct the record, inform the public, and honor the Open Meetings Act they claimed to be following.
The missing October 3 meetings are more than a clerical omission; they are evidence of a deliberate decision to keep citizens in the dark.
And as the investigation continues, the question Odessa must now ask is not whether the math was wrong — it’s whether the city’s leadership was ever honest about it.
HEADLINE TAKEAWAY:
“We’ll Never Rebuild Public Trust.” — Councilman Craig Stoker, Sept. 26, 2025
HEADLINES INVESTIGATION: “We’ll Never Regain Public Trust” — Inside the City’s Tax-Rate Cover-Up is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>Councilman Hanie Holds The Line is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>City Manager John Beckmeyer had previously promised that the City’s use of a new zero-based budget would save money, yet the budget passed Tuesday night featured a 9.4% overall increase of nearly $12 million, bringing the total budget to $305,193,877.
A notable change in the budget was the addition of nearly $1 million to staff the City Manager’s office with seven public relations and communications personnel. This came alongside an almost doubling of the City Secretary’s budget and a 76% increase in the Planning and Development department’s budget. On the other hand, the budget also sharply reduced the number of police officers.
While the City Council emphasized a small two-cent reduction in the property tax rate, the data presented showed that most taxpayers will actually pay more in city taxes due to rising property values.
In addition to higher property taxes, the city also increased water and sewer rates by 3% and trash rates by 3.5%. These hikes were approved despite ongoing service failures, which have left residents without water for days and with overflowing dumpsters.
Despite the nearly 10% increase in the budget, Councilperson Denise Swanner praised city staff for their hard work and lauded the value of the new zero-based budgeting process. However, there were several budgetary issues pointed out by citizens at the meeting. For example, the water and sewer fund’s revenues were budgeted to decrease by 1.7%, even though the council voted to raise water and sewer rates by 3%. Questions were raised about how revenues could decrease while rates were increasing.
Councilman Chris Hanie had a different perspective. He urged his fellow council members to drop the property tax rate to the “no new revenue” rate or lower, and to maintain current water, sewer, and trash rates. Hanie pointed out that the city will still be sitting on a surplus of over $272 million, equivalent to almost a full year of expenses. In a comment to Odessa Headlines, Councilman Hanie said, “I was really disappointed that Mayor Joven and the rest of the council showed so little concern for the difficulties our taxpayers are facing. With inflation, everyone is struggling to make ends meet, and we could have easily found some savings in our budget or used some of the $123 million general fund balance the city currently holds. I really wanted to hold the line and help our taxpayers, but I couldn’t get any support from City Manager Beckmeyer, Mayor Joven, or the other council members.”
Councilman Hanie Holds The Line is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>City Manager’s Political Power Play: is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>City Resources Used for Political Attacks
When the City of Odessa’s Facebook page published a post attacking a press release from former Odessa Development Corporation board members Kris Crow and Jeff Russell, many residents were shocked. The comments section filled with criticism about the unprofessional tone of the post. The city’s communications apparatus appeared to have been weaponized to serve the political interests of Beckmeyer and his allies.
The Beckmeyers’ Political Ties and Ambitions
John Beckmeyer’s background as Executive Director of the Republican Party of Texas gave him significant experience in strategic communications, fundraising, and political operations. His wife, Teresa, plays a similar role as Senior Advisor for the Saulsbury family, representing their interests in political causes across the state and nation. This influence now appears to be directed locally, where it seems a strategy has been devised to exert political control in Odessa.
Beckmeyers’ Involvement in the March 2024 Republican Primary
During the contentious 2024 Republican Primary elections, John and Teresa provided strategy and guidance to the incumbent Ector County Republican Party officials and worked to influence the outcome. For the most part their strategy failed and local Republicans were replaced as a wave of Democrats, under the direction of Ronnie Lewis, crossed over to vote in the Republican Primary. Also, almost 1,500 voters who had never before voted in any primary election headed to the polls to often cast only one vote on the entire ballot as they voted for Donna Kelm over incumbent Tisha Crow.
It’s important to note that prior to the primary and at Teresa’s request, the Ector County Republican Party contracted with the “Allied Special Intelligence Group” to provide a two day strategic planning session focused on identifying and counter-acting possible community threats from radicalized groups. It was the Allied meetings that Ronnie Lewis and his team made much to do about characterizing the training as secret meetings on how to spy on and take out your enemies.
The Private Meetings and Unveiling of the Strategy
After the 2024 Republican Primary, I was invited by Teresa Beckmeyer to a private meeting at the Beckmeyer residence. Present were John, Teresa, and Bubba Saulsbury (via Zoom).The purpose was to discuss the Odessa City Council and mayoral races and I was briefed on a campaign strategy crafted by political consultant Matt Armstrong.

Armstrong’s plan focused on re-electing incumbents Javier Joven, Denise Swanner, and Mark Matta by exploiting supposed racial divides, particularly among the Hispanic community. The strategy proposed staging divisive events to provoke anger among Hispanic voters and drive them to support Joven. While this racially charged tactic raised serious ethical concerns, the Beckmeyers were steadfast in their support, despite the risk that it might create or deepen racial tensions in Odessa.
As the discussion progressed, they asked me to join the campaign. While some aspects of the Beckmeyer-Armstrong plan were typical of most political campaigns, the use of racially inflammatory tactics and the plan to deploy city resources made me hesitant. I also didn’t like the fact that a lot of the Beckmeyers’ motivation to re-elect the incumbents seemed to be to protect John’s $250,000+benefits per year City salary.
In an email recap sent out by Teresa Beckmeyer and copied to husband John, one notable agenda item highlighted the need to use the City of Odessa’s social media accounts to “set the narrative” in favor of their chosen candidates. The idea of using taxpayer resources to run a political campaign was uncharted territory and deeply troubling.

Also discussed were the details around Councilman Mark Matta’s relationship with the wife of a City employee. The Beckmeyers believed that Matta should either get ahead of this story or should not run for reelection and should perhaps even resign his seat. The allegations that had been made by the wife’s husband were serious and the woman’s husband was promising to make it a campaign issue. John, it seems, had been briefed on this situation by the employee’s department head. On the agenda recap provided by Teresa this item was listed as “Candidate problem – 1. Come out publicly or drop out and let us find a new candidate. John/Jeff”.
The Continued Push for Influence
A second meeting followed on March 28, 2024, where the Beckmeyers reiterated their plan to create racial tensions to mobilize support for Joven. They confirmed that Matt Armstrong would lead the campaigns of Joven, Swanner, and Matta, with plans to establish several political action committees (PACs) to support their efforts. Despite my expressed reservations, it became clear that this strategy was moving forward.
In subsequent conversations I had with Armstrong, the focus remained on the “divide and conquer” approach. The Beckmeyers, along with Armstrong, were committed to using racially charged tactics to sway the election in favor of their chosen candidates. This strategy, more typical of liberal campaigns, was alarming in a community like Odessa, which has traditionally been merit-based and inclusive.
A Joke Becomes a Political Tool
During a recent City Council meeting, a light-hearted presentation by Kris Crow welcoming Councilman Vasquez to the Republican Party took a dark turn. Though intended as a joke, Vasquez later claimed in the Odessa American that he was attacked and reaffirmed his Democratic identity, stating he crossed over in the Republican primary solely to vote against certain Republicans, most notably Kris’ wife Tisha who had served for the past fourteen years as the Chair of the Ector County Republican Party.
Joven, Swanner, and Matta quickly issued nearly identical statements condemning Crow’s “attack,” signaling a coordinated effort to exploit the incident as part of the Beckmeyer led campaign.
Coordinated Messaging and the Bigger Picture
As the election heats up, the incumbents have released a series of videos with nearly identical messaging, all filmed with the same backdrop and footage signaling that they are all working in concert. The themes are clear: while expressing a love for Odessa, work to divide the community along racial lines, pit groups against each other, and cast successful white citizens as part of Odessa’s problems. These tactics align perfectly with the Beckmeyer strategy discussed in those meetings. Many online commentators have also raised questions about whether city resources were used to produce the videos.
The Broader Implications for Odessa
Voters expect city managers and other key administrators to stay out of political campaigns, focusing instead on running the city effectively. Yet, Beckmeyer’s entanglement in local politics has already harmed Odessa. Under his watch, the city’s bond rating has been pulled by the two major ratings groups (S&P and Moody’s) as governance seems to have taken a back seat to political scheming. The use of city resources to support specific candidates is a breach of public trust that should not be overlooked and the City Council should take quick and decisive action to stop any abusive use of taxpayer funded resources by Beckmeyer and should also appoint a special committee to investigate the extent to which the Beckmeyers are attempting to tip the scales in the current Council elections.
Obvious Questions For Odessa Voters
The question for Odessa now is whether its leadership should be focused on serving the public or on pushing a political agenda that divides the community.
The actions of the Beckmeyers and their associates show a clear conflict between public duty and personal ambition, raising serious concerns about the future of our city. Voters will no doubt have to factor the tactics being deployed by Joven, Swanner, and Matta and their handlers before they cast their vote this November and will also have to evaluate whether or not John Beckmeyer should continue in his job as City Manager.
Odessa Headlines will continue to follow this and other local elections as the November election nears.
Photo Credit: Chat GPT generated image.
City Manager’s Political Power Play: is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>BREAKING NEWS: Bass Pro Shops Coming To Odessa is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>The announcement came this morning from Bass Pro Shops via a press release which can be read here: Bass Pro Shops, North America’s premier outdoor and conservation company, updates plans for new destination store in Texas to serve Odessa and Midland metro markets
In a statement released this morning by the City of Odessa, Odessa Mayor Javier Joven applauded the cooperation between ICA, Bass Pro Shops, the City of Odessa and The Odessa Development Corporation (IDC).
Mayor Javier Joven releases statement on Bass Pro Shops and Tracker Boats coming to Odessa
A new and brighter future in Odessa, Texas begins today with the exciting announcement that Bass Pro Shops and Tracker Boats will be located in the city. A new 100,000-square-foot facility will be built south of US Highway 191 along with Tracker Boats, all on a 16-acre tract of land. This significant development is the result of the hard work and dedication of John Bushman and ICA Development LLC, along with the City of Odessa and the Odessa Development Corp.
The collaboration between these entities, guided by the efforts of ICA staff and the planning division, has made the dream of bringing a major retail store like Bass Pro Shops to Odessa a reality. This milestone in Odessa’s retail development will pave the way for more well-known brands to come to the city, providing residents with a wider range of retail choices and boosting the local economy.
The impact of this announcement on the community cannot be overstated. The arrival of Bass Pro Shops and Tracker Boats signifies a new era of growth and prosperity for Odessa. It is a testament to the city’s potential and its ability to attract big-name retailers. This development will not only create jobs and generate revenue for the city, but it will also enhance the overall quality of life for residents by providing them with access to top-quality products and services.
Odessa, often referred to as the City of Light and Love, is on the cusp of a bright and promising future. The unity and collaboration demonstrated by John Bushman, ICA Development LLC, the City of Odessa, and the Odessa Development Corp. serve as a shining example of what can be achieved when a community works together towards a common goal. With this new development, Odessa is poised to become a thriving hub of commerce and opportunity, attracting visitors from near and far.
As we look towards the future, it is clear that Odessa is stronger together. This exciting announcement of Bass Pro Shops and Tracker Boat’s arrival marks the beginning of a new chapter in the city’s history. With determination, hard work, and a shared vision for prosperity, Odessa is well-equipped to embrace the changes and challenges that lie ahead. The future is indeed bright in Odessa, and it all begins today with this groundbreaking announcement. It is expected to open in Spring of 2025.
Statement from Bass Pro Shops: https://about.passpro.com/newsroom
?BrighterFuture #OdessaProud
City of Odessa Press Release – 2/23/2024
BREAKING NEWS: Bass Pro Shops Coming To Odessa is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>City of Odessa Says Water Delivery Contract With ECUD Is Void is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>In records obtained from the City of Odessa via a public records request the City informed the Ector County Utility District (ECUD) that the water delivery contract that was negotiated and signed just prior to the swearing in of the new City Council in late 2020 is void and must be renegotiated due to the fact that this contract was signed by ECUD Board member Tommy Ervin who lacked the legal authority to execute the contract. This letter, dated September 1, 2023, also informs ECUD that until such time as a new contract can be negotiated that the City would sell water to ECUD on a month to month basis.
As reported by Odessa Headlines, Ervin’s eligibility to hold public office has been contested due to a number of felony convictions from which Ervin, despite his repeated claims to the contrary, has not been pardoned. Under Texas law Subsection 141.00I(a)(4) a convicted felon is ineligible to hold public office.
Subsection 141.00I(a)(4) of the Election Code provides that to be eligible as a candidate for public office a person must “have not been finally convicted of a felony from which the person has not been pardoned or otherwise released from the resulting disabilities.”
The restoration of a convicted felon’s qualification to vote under Election Code subsection 1 l.002(a)(4)(A) after fully discharging a sentence does not restore his or her eligibility to hold public office under Election Code subsection 141.001(a)(4).
The ineligibility of a convicted felon to hold public office was ruled on and affirmed by current Attorney General Ken Paxton in 2017 in ruling KP-0251.
The latest action by the City of Odessa appears to have been triggered by an August 16, 2023 letter from ECUD claiming that the City had overcharged them for water. However, the issue of whether or not the current contract was valid appears to have surfaced in the past. According to email threads obtained by Odessa Headlines in November 2022 then Assistant City Attorney Dan Jones informed then City Attorney Natasha Brooks that it was his legal opinion that the ECUD contract was void due to Ervin’s unpardoned felonies.
Odessa Headlines contacted ECUD for comment but received no response to our inquiry.
City of Odessa Says Water Delivery Contract With ECUD Is Void is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>Steady Progress Being Made At City Hall is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>“While I’m never one to want to spend taxpayer money, our ability to use some outside consultants to help us quickly get to where we need to be has been necessary as we worked through cleaning up some messes left by the previous administration.” Joven continued. When asked about what he considered “messes” Joven quickly pointed to the recently completed investigation into the allegations made by Casey Hallmark. “In order to conduct a fair and unbiased investigation Council felt it absolutely necessary to hire an outside law firm to conduct this investigation. Council wanted to ensure that the work completed was completely untainted and therefore we hired Davidson-Sheen and let them do their work without interference. Would I have liked to not spend the over $12,000 that was required to complete this work – you bet. However, Ms. Hallmark’s allegations were serious and we needed to handle this properly so we could move forward.”
Joven also commented about the ongoing investigation into a potential Odessa Fire Rescue incident. “That’s another mess the City is having to deal with. When Mr. Bernal took over as City Manager he discovered that this incident hadn’t been properly reported or investigated and he felt like it demanded further investigation to ensure that the City knew exactly what had happened so that we could guarantee that proper procedures are in place to keep such an incident from happening in the future. From what Attorney Sheen has discovered so far there were a lot of failures along the chain of command, in the way the incident was reported and followed up on. This is clearly a case where, if the prior administration had done their job properly, we would not now be forced to spend tens of thousands of dollars on cleaning this up.”
Joven also stated that the city has also retained other outside law firms to handle some litigation work for the city but, although these attorneys bill at a higher hourly rate than the City internal attorneys, the City isn’t on the hook for any benefits costs, office expenses, and other costs. Joven also noted that outside attorneys are paid only for the actual time worked on litigation for the city and with the expenses of the City legal department being trimmed significantly the current expenditures are more than covered by the legal department’s 2022-2023 budget.
“I wish I could tell taxpayers that we can avoid some of these legal costs but the reality is that with the City there is no such thing as a ‘routine’ lawsuit as everytime a City employee is involved in the slightest of accidents the personal injury lawyers come out of the woodwork and are looking for a payday. I believe it’s important that we have lawyers representing us that do litigation work every day. Dan Jones is a great attorney and is a skilled litigator but, as Interim City Attorney, he has a lot of plates in the air and I don’t think it’s fair or in the City’s best interest to have him litigating cases.” Joven stated.
Joven also discussed that during the previous administration of Natasha Brooks that she too hired outside council and had agreements with Cotton Bledsoe, Brockett, McNeel & Pocsik and others. Joven said that many of these firms are no longer being used by the city and that the City legal department is operating efficiently even though it has fewer attorneys on staff than before. “I suppose it helps when some of your senior legal staff are not regularly taking three hour lunches to do Zumba at Crunch Fitness’.
“The one legal expense that frustrates me most is the $300,000 plus that city taxpayers have had to pay to defend the City against the Odessa American’s lawsuit. The OA keeps losing and appealing, losing and appealing. This lawsuit, which the courts have repeatedly said has no merit, should have concluded long ago but the OA just can’t admit they lost. Continuing to spend taxpayer money on this case really frustrates me and the fact that the OA wants the City to cover some $650,000 in attorneys fees that they have spent to pursue this failed case is unbelievable.” Joven stated.
Joven then noted that during a recent City Council meeting it was discussed that the City’s policy and procedure manual hadn’t been updated since 2008. “Another mess left behind to clean up. I think everyone knows that workplace laws have changed dramatically since 2008 and for the City not to have been regularly updating this important HR document and ensuring that our staff is properly trained on these matters is really incredible. This is a basic thing that we’re now having to spend $10,000 of taxpayer money in order to get us compliant ASAP.”
Odessa Headlines also spoke with several City Council members to ask their perspective on the work being done at City Hall. District 1 City Councilman Mark Matta said that “It’s refreshing to be confident that our City staff is getting the things done that need doing. I agree with Councilman Thompson that it’s not the job of City Council to micromanage the City’s daily operations and, for the first time since I’ve been on Council, I believe our city manager and city attorney are getting our city to hit on all cylinders.”
At Large City Councilwoman Denise Swanner echoed Matta’s comments: “While it’s been a lot of work to get us to where we’re at and we’ve come under attack from some of the old established power brokers, I know that we’re on the right path. My confidence in our Interim City Manager and City Attorney continues to grow and I see us quickly working through a lot of the problems that were left behind by the old administration. I’m very proud of the work being done and I’m excited for our city’s future.”
District 5 City Councilman Chris Hanie stated “The most encouraging thing I see right now is that we have city employees staying – not leaving – because of the changes they see being made. Positive changes. Changes that are moving our city forward. When I’m at City Hall I can see that people are happily coming to work and that’s exciting.”
Greg Connell, District 4 City Councilman stated he was pleased with how things with the City are proceeding. “We still have a lot of work ahead of us but I’m pleased with the progress that has been made. Knowing that our City Manager and City Attorney are working with City Council as a team has greatly increased my confidence that we’re getting things in order. Both Gapi and Dan are doing an excellent job. I know that public service is near and dear to their hearts and they’ve both stepped up and answered the call during a very difficult situation. I think that Odessa residents are going to continue to see a lot of positive changes and I know the entire Council stands ready to serve our city and to keep the improvements coming.”
Joven concluded the interview by saying “While it’s been a lot of work and we’ve taken some flack for the work we’ve had to do, I’m proud of the fact that our City is becoming better day by day. The work Mr. Bernal and Mr. Jones and all of the rest of the staff have been doing has been excellent and they’ve had to work through a lot of thorny issues left behind by the prior administration. I couldn’t be prouder of where I see our City heading as we continue to change the way the City interacts with our residents and how we are working to meet the needs of our city.”
Odessa Headlines also requested comment from District 2 City Councilman Steve Thompson and District 3 Councilman Gilbert Vasquez but received no response.
UPDATE: 3/24/2023
While District 2 City Councilman Steve Thompson missed our publication deadline due to other commitments, he did respond to our request for comment and Odessa Headlines wanted to include his comments in our story.
District 2 City Councilman Steve Thompson stated that while he continues to have objections to the way in which Interim City Manager Agape Bernal and City Attorney Dan Jones were appointed he does believe that “We are now getting some things accomplished.” Thompson did say that he feels “Dan Jones is doing a good job” but expressed concern about Bernal saying “I think he’s in over his head.”
Thompson also stated that he continues to believe that the T2 contract “was illegally entered into” and that he voted no on funding this contract. However, he said that “once we got Dr. Hank, the mental scientist, off the team because he could not or would not provide his credentials, the other folks seem to be doing a good job. I think the process has been good to this point.”
Steady Progress Being Made At City Hall is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]><strong>Casey Hallmark’s Accusations Against Odessa Council Crumble After Investigation</strong> is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>As a result of Hallmark’s allegations, the city hired Tommy Sheen, a Lubbock based attorney, to conduct a thorough independent investigation of Hallmark’s claims.
During Tuesday’s City Council meeting Sheen delivered his findings to the council and methodically detailed the steps he undertook in the investigation.
Sheen pointed out that all witness statements were taken under oath during the investigation, subjecting them to the same criminal perjury laws that are used to interview witnesses in a court room.
Sheen first addressed the allegations Hallmark made against Joven.
During her two appearances at the speaker stand, Hallmark alleged that Joven had bullied and threatened her and had said that he would “be happy to accept your letter of resignation”.
Hallmark later embellished her statements to local media and a Texas Monthly reporter to include charges that Joven had refused to address her by her maiden name of Hallmark after her marriage and further claimed that Joven had visited her office for sometimes hours at a time and told her to “watch her back” because the Odessa Police department was “full of murderers.” During her statement to Sheen, Hallmark also claimed that Joven had discussed the cover up of the death of a prostitute injured by OPD.
In his presentation to Council, Sheen brought forward the eyewitness testimony of Alexa Moulakis who had witnessed the exchange Joven had with Hallmark in her office in February 0f 2022.
Moulakis, who also worked for Downtown Odessa, stated that she set outside door of Hallmark’s office approximately 20 feet away and could clearly hear the conversation through Hallmark’s open door. Moulakis confirmed that Joven’s entire conversation lasted approximately 2 hours and testified that the Mayor did not make any statements regarding “crooks” and people who cannot be trusted around Odessa. Moulakis further denies that Joven made any mention of the OPD being “full of murderers” or of an OPD cover up of the death of a prostitute. Moulakis did state that she heard the Mayor say “prostitute” but in the context of efforts to clean up illicit behavior on Second Street.
In her testimony, Moulakis characterized the conversation as exhibiting a “get-to-know-you” tenor and did not witness any threats or raised voices. Moulakis further stated that during her time as interim director of DOI prior to the hiring of Hallmark that she had met with Joven on multiple occasions that, while she and the Mayor may have held dissimilar political views, Joven supported her work and treated her respectfully.
While giving her statement, Moulakis volunteered information regarding the working conditions under Hallmark.
Moulakis described Hallmark as an unpolished and aggressive person who was not a “people person” and said Hallmark had an aggressive micromanaging management style.
She also stated that Hallmark had bullied her on multiple occasions and had a habit of taking credit for wins and passed the blame for losses onto others. Moulakis, who no longer works for the city, also stated that she believes Hallmark was responsible for spreading rumors and accusations about certain Council members having an affair with other city staff.
Sheen also addressed the allegation regarding Joven asking for Hallmark’s resignation noting that Joven, in his sworn statement, denied ever making this statement and further noted that nothing in the city charter or the DOI bylaws would allow a mayor the ability to hire, fire, or discipline a DOI employee.
According to Sheen’s investigation, Hallmark’s allegations of bullying by Councilman Matta stemmed from postings made on a Facebook page called “Odessa Whisteblowers”. This page made sexual accusations against several Councilmembers and had only two members, one of which was Hallmark. Due to the scandalous sexual nature of the posts made, Matta did state that he felt the need to rebuff Hallmark for her association with the Odessa Whisteblowers page but at no time did he attempt to bully Hallmark or get her fired. Sheen stated that no evidence – in the form of emails or any other evidence from Hallmark – substantiated Hallmark’s charges against Matta.
Next up were the allegations Hallmark made against Hanie.
Hallmark alleged that Hanie had gotten within 5-6 inches of her face at the Christmas parade on December 3, 2022. Hanie, she claimed, was upset over the wording on the car banner DOI provided him listing him as “Councilperson”. Hallmark claimed that Hanie, a devout and conservative Christian, had screamed into her face “I am not a fuc*** ‘councilperson.’ I am a councilman.”
Sheen’s investigation discovered that there were several witnesses who saw and heard the exchange between Sheen and Hanie. Hanie’s description of his exchange between him and Hallmark as being in a low conversational tone where he requested to be addressed as a Councilman and not person was observed by Alyssa Deutsch, Hanie’s stepdaughter, and Bobby Swanner, Councilwoman’s Swanner’s husband. Deutsch was standing approximately five feet away from Hanie during the exchange and stated that Hanie did not raise his voice nor get in Hallmark’s face. Bobby Swanner stated he was approximately fifteen feet away and likewise did not hear Hanie raise his voice nor get in Hallmark’s face. Based upon these two eyewitness accounts, Sheen concluded that Hallmark’s claims against Hanie were unsubstantiated.
As he concluded, Sheen stated that his firm was “unable to find sufficient evidence to corroborate the allegations levied by Casey Hallmark against Mayor Joven, Councilman Mark Matta and Councilman Chris Hanie.”
Hallmark, who has continued to repeat and add to her story over past months, was in attendance at the City Council meeting but offered no statements or rebuttals during the meeting.
<strong>Casey Hallmark’s Accusations Against Odessa Council Crumble After Investigation</strong> is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>ODC To Host Joint City Council/County Commissioner Meeting is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>“This is the first meeting of its kind between our three entities with the purpose of getting our newly elected elected and appointed officials on the same page, an expectation that I believe every citizen of our county has. I believe this is an important first step in working towards common goals that serves the great citizens of Ector County,” said Judge Fawcett.
“It is important for our city and county officials to be on the same page with our interlocal agreements as well as our common vision for how government serves the citizens into the future. In order to best serve the citizens of Odessa, we must have a great relationship with our partners on the Commissioners’ Court,” explained Mayor Joven.
“Economic Development in Ector County and the city of Odessa rely on the cooperation of these two institutions. The fact that these two institutions are willing to sit down and work together towards common goals is a bright light, especially when it comes to economic development. This shows good will and positive developments to all of the citizens as well as site selectors and potential businesses looking to move into the area,” exclaims ODC Board Chairman Crow.
The meeting will take place beginning at 6:00 p.m. Tuesday, February 21, 2023, at the Electronics and Technology Building on the Odessa Campus. The meeting will take place in the Saulsbury Conference Room.
The agenda for this meeting will be posted in accordance with (insert local government code regarding postings) 72 hours in advance with the accompanying agenda.
This press release was provided to Odessa Headlines by the Odessa Development Corporation.
ODC To Host Joint City Council/County Commissioner Meeting is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>Swanner Working To Improve City Permitting and Inspection is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>“My short period of time here was met with much internal resistance, and often, a very hostile place to come to work.”
Consultant Sylvia Carrillo-TrevinoA 2019 report authored by consultant Sylvia Carrillo-Trevino while under contract with the City of Odessa offers a detailed and candid review of the lack of customer service from city staff. Email chains obtained by Odessa Headlines show the report was delivered to former City Manager Michael Marrero and Assistant City Manager Phillip Urrutia on August 19, 2019 but seems to have never been provided to City Council nor were many of the suggested actions undertaken by City staff.
According to the report and records obtained by Odessa Headlines, Trevino spent approximately 120 days observing city operations at a cost of almost $37,0000. While the report focuses on problems within the planning, zoning, and building inspection departments it also offers important insights into the overall culture inside city hall and provides detailed advice on how to address shortcomings within several key city departments.
Entitled “Development Process Overview” the nineteen page report focused on key problems within the City’s Planning & Zoning, and Building & Inspection departments and suggests that “Instead of playing ‘gotcha’ with the customers, let’s develop the attitude of partners helping one another along the development sequence. Good development starts with a good attitude on both sides; partners not adversaries.”
“When I ran for City Council one of the areas I promised to focus on was the continual problems that were being reported with the Planning and Inspection Department.” stated Odessa City Council At Large Denise Swanner during an interview with Odessa Headlines. “As I campaigned I heard time and again how difficult the City was when you wanted to build a new property or improve an existing property. I had many conversations with builders, developers, remodeling contractors, and property owners who were frustrated with the process of permitting and inspection and they were begging for change.”
The report notes that “Development is the economic engine of a city. It must have the ability to run as a well-oiled machine that delivers consistently, timely, and with a good customer service attitude. This is a paradigm that must come from the elected officials and the City Manager. It must be consistently delivered at every opportunity, and when issues of poor customer service arise, they are dealt with swiftly and seriously.”
“Shortly after I was elected in 2020, I attempted to broker an open and honest conversation between Odessa’s builder and developer communities and City staff. Many builders and contractors were invited but only two showed up to face a group of eight or nine City staff – including City Manager Marrero – who spent most of the hour and half long meeting describing what a great job they were doing. I didn’t know anything about Syliva’s report at that time but mind you my meeting took place just about six months after this report was apparently delivered. When I read that report it exactly mirrors the problems that had been described to me and it is very frustrating to me that few, if any, of her suggestions were being implemented.” said Swanner.
When asked why she wasn’t able to get more builders to attend the meeting, Swanner responded with one word: “Retaliation – I believe that most builders, contractors and developers were very afraid to rock the boat. They believed that if they were honest about the problems they were facing that City staff would take it out on them and they would have even more problems getting their projects done.”
A number of key suggestions were included in the final report:
“In the current environment, the customer is left to fend for themselves and navigate the development maze.”
Consultant Sylvia Carrillo-Trevino
Throughout, the report advocates for a partnership approach with developers, builders, and property owners. Instead of seeming to fight with citizens, the report states that city staff needs to be trained to be collaborative in assisting customers in meeting the city’s requirements.
“The report is dead on when it concludes that we, as the City, must focus on the “Why” of what we do. It correctly states that if we make the process too cumbersome then people are just going to build in other places where it’s easier to build.” stated Swanner. “Back two years ago this was what drove me to want to improve our process. I want Odessa to grow. I want to make it easy to do business here. I want our citizens to know that we hear them, we care about their problems, and we’re here to help, not hinder. With the changes being made in our city administration I am more than confident that we’ll finally be able to make the changes we’ve needed for so long.”
When asked about her next steps Swanner stated “I am currently working on having a meeting with local builders, developers, and contractors to hear about their grievances. Unlike my prior attempt, I will be managing this meeting and who attends, and no City staff will be invited to attend. I want this meeting to be a productive exchange of experiences and ideas in a very open, non-threatening forum and then I hope to be able to take my findings to City staff and begin the work needed to make Odessa’s building process the easiest, most streamlined and efficient process it can be. I really want to make it pleasant for people to do business with our city as I believe this will give us a huge competitive advantage over other cities.”
Swanner Working To Improve City Permitting and Inspection is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>Joven, Swanner & Matta Advocate For Odessa With State Legislature is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>“West Texas can easily get forgotten in Austin if we aren’t constantly advocating for our area.” stated Mayor Joven. “Odessa and Midland provide a huge amount of wealth to the state via severance taxes but, because we don’t have the population base of say a Dallas or Houston, we often get shorted when it comes to state allocations. The reality is that energy production takes a huge toll on our infrastructure, and it is imperative that the State understand our needs to keep this money-making engine running which benefits the entire state.”
Specifically, the current expansion plans for Loop 338 were discussed. “Loop 338 has become a very important transportation through-way for Odessa and it is important that we continue to prioritize the improvements on the loop.” said Councilwoman Swanner. “Currently overpasses and a number of other long-term enhancements are underway, and we discussed how to continue to get state funding for this work.”
Also discussed were public school needs. Led by Senator Kevin Sparks much of the discussion centered around two key topics: funding, and student discipline. Senator Sparks is pushing for legislation that will allow schools new options in dealing with discipline issues within our schools. “While I am on the City Council and it’s the school board and not the City Council that deals with our schools, I found this discussion to be very important. I have kids in ECISD schools and I am very concerned about student discipline as unruly students hinder the ability of students that want to learn to focus on their work. I really hope Senator Sparks is able to introduce legislation that will give ECISD some new tools to deal with bad student behavior.” stated Councilman Mark Matta.
The Odessa delegation will be back at the State Capital tomorrow and then will travel home tomorrow afternoon.
Joven, Swanner & Matta Advocate For Odessa With State Legislature is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>