1,
'price' => $product->get_price(),
) );
if ( function_exists( 'wc_get_price_including_tax' ) ) { // WC 3.0+
$price = wc_get_price_including_tax( $product, $args );
} else { // WC < 3.0
$price = $product->get_price_including_tax( $args['qty'], $args['price'] );
}
return $price;
}
/**
* For a given product, and optionally price/qty, work out the sign-up fee with tax excluded, based on store settings.
*
* @since 1.0.0 - Migrated from WooCommerce Subscriptions v2.2.0
* @param WC_Product $product
* @param array $args
* @return float
*/
function wcs_get_price_excluding_tax( $product, $args = array() ) {
$args = wp_parse_args( $args, array(
'qty' => 1,
'price' => $product->get_price(),
) );
if ( function_exists( 'wc_get_price_excluding_tax' ) ) { // WC 3.0+
$price = wc_get_price_excluding_tax( $product, $args );
} else { // WC < 3.0
$price = $product->get_price_excluding_tax( $args['qty'], $args['price'] );
}
return $price;
}
/**
* Returns a 'from' prefix if you want to show where prices start at.
*
* @since 1.0.0 - Migrated from WooCommerce Subscriptions v2.2.0
* @return string
*/
function wcs_get_price_html_from_text( $product = '' ) {
if ( function_exists( 'wc_get_price_html_from_text' ) ) { // WC 3.0+
$price_html_from_text = wc_get_price_html_from_text();
} else { // WC < 3.0
$price_html_from_text = $product->get_price_html_from_text();
}
return $price_html_from_text;
}
/**
* Get an array of the prices, used to help determine min/max values.
*
* @since 1.0.0 - Migrated from WooCommerce Subscriptions v2.2.0
*/
function wcs_get_variation_prices( $variation, $variable_product ) {
return array(
'price' => apply_filters( 'woocommerce_variation_prices_price', WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_price( $variation ), $variation, $variable_product ),
'regular_price' => apply_filters( 'woocommerce_variation_prices_regular_price', WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_regular_price( $variation, 'edit' ), $variation, $variable_product ),
'sale_price' => apply_filters( 'woocommerce_variation_prices_sale_price', WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_sale_price( $variation, 'edit' ), $variation, $variable_product ),
'sign_up_fee' => apply_filters( 'woocommerce_variation_prices_sign_up_fee', WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_sign_up_fee( $variation ), $variation, $variable_product ),
);
}
/**
* Get an array of the minimum and maximum priced variations based on subscription billing terms.
*
* @param array $child_variation_ids the IDs of product variation children ids
* @return array Array containing the min and max variation prices and billing data
* @since 1.0.0 - Migrated from WooCommerce Subscriptions v2.2.0
*/
function wcs_get_min_max_variation_data( $variable_product, $child_variation_ids = array() ) {
if ( empty( $child_variation_ids ) ) {
$child_variation_ids = is_callable( array( $variable_product, 'get_visible_children' ) ) ? $variable_product->get_visible_children() : $variable_product->get_children( true );
}
$variations_data = array();
foreach ( $child_variation_ids as $variation_id ) {
if ( $variation = wc_get_product( $variation_id ) ) {
$prices = wcs_get_variation_prices( $variation, $variable_product );
foreach ( $prices as $price_key => $amount ) {
if ( '' !== $amount ) {
if ( 'incl' === get_option( 'woocommerce_tax_display_shop' ) ) {
$prices[ $price_key ] = wcs_get_price_including_tax( $variable_product, array( 'price' => $amount ) );
} else {
$prices[ $price_key ] = wcs_get_price_excluding_tax( $variable_product, array( 'price' => $amount ) );
}
}
}
$variations_data[ $variation_id ] = array(
'price' => $prices['price'],
'regular_price' => $prices['regular_price'],
'sale_price' => $prices['sale_price'],
'subscription' => array(
'sign_up_fee' => $prices['sign_up_fee'],
'period' => WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_period( $variation ),
'interval' => WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_interval( $variation ),
'trial_length' => WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_trial_length( $variation ),
'trial_period' => WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_trial_period( $variation ),
'length' => WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_length( $variation ),
),
);
}
}
return wcs_calculate_min_max_variations( $variations_data );
}
/**
* Determine the minimum and maximum values for a set of structured subscription
* price data in a form created by @see wcs_get_min_max_variation_data()
*
* @param array $variations_data the IDs of product variation children ids
* @return array
* @since 1.0.0 - Migrated from WooCommerce Subscriptions v2.2.0
*/
function wcs_calculate_min_max_variations( $variations_data ) {
$lowest_initial_amount = $highest_initial_amount = $lowest_price = $highest_price = '';
$shortest_initial_period = $longest_initial_period = $shortest_trial_period = $longest_trial_period = $shortest_trial_length = $longest_trial_length = '';
$longest_initial_interval = $shortest_initial_interval = $variable_subscription_period = $variable_subscription_period_interval = '';
$lowest_regular_price = $highest_regular_price = $lowest_sale_price = $highest_sale_price = $max_subscription_period = $max_subscription_period_interval = '';
$variable_subscription_sign_up_fee = $variable_subscription_trial_period = $variable_subscription_trial_length = $variable_subscription_length = $variable_subscription_sign_up_fee = $variable_subscription_trial_period = $variable_subscription_trial_length = $variable_subscription_length = '';
$min_variation_id = $max_variation_id = null;
$variations_data_prices_list = array();
$variations_data_sign_up_fees_list = array();
$variations_data_periods_list = array();
$variations_data_intervals_list = array();
$variations_data_trial_lengths_list = array();
$variations_data_trial_periods_list = array();
$variations_data_lengths_list = array();
foreach ( $variations_data as $variation_id => $variation_data ) {
$is_max = $is_min = false;
if ( '' === $variation_data['price'] && empty( $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'] ) ) {
continue;
}
$variations_data_prices_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_prices_list, array( $variation_data['price'] ) ) );
$variations_data_sign_up_fees_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_sign_up_fees_list, array( empty( $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'] ) ? 0 : $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'] ) ) );
$variations_data_periods_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_periods_list, array( $variation_data['subscription']['period'] ) ) );
$variations_data_intervals_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_intervals_list, array( $variation_data['subscription']['interval'] ) ) );
$variations_data_trial_lengths_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_trial_lengths_list, array( empty( $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] ) ? 0 : $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] ) ) );
$variations_data_trial_periods_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_trial_periods_list, array( $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) ) );
$variations_data_lengths_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_lengths_list, array( $variation_data['subscription']['length'] ) ) );
$has_free_trial = '' !== $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] && $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] > 0;
// Determine some recurring price flags
$is_lowest_price = $variation_data['price'] < $lowest_price || '' === $lowest_price;
$is_longest_period = wcs_get_longest_period( $variable_subscription_period, $variation_data['subscription']['period'] ) === $variation_data['subscription']['period'];
$is_longest_interval = $variation_data['subscription']['interval'] >= $variable_subscription_period_interval || '' === $variable_subscription_period_interval;
// Find the amount the subscriber will have to pay up-front
if ( $has_free_trial ) {
$initial_amount = $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'];
$initial_period = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'];
$initial_interval = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'];
} else {
$initial_amount = (float) $variation_data['price'] + (float) $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'];
$initial_period = $variation_data['subscription']['period'];
$initial_interval = $variation_data['subscription']['interval'];
}
// We have a free trial & no sign-up fee, so need to choose the longest free trial (and maybe the shortest)
if ( $has_free_trial && 0 == $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'] ) {
// First variation
if ( '' === $longest_trial_period ) {
$is_min = true;
// If two variations have the same free trial, choose the variation with the lowest recurring price for the longest period
} elseif ( $variable_subscription_trial_period === $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] && $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] === $variable_subscription_trial_length ) {
// If the variation has the lowest recurring price, it's the cheapest
if ( $is_lowest_price ) {
$is_min = true;
// When current variation's free trial is the same as the lowest, it's the cheaper if it has a longer billing schedule
} elseif ( $variation_data['price'] === $lowest_price ) {
if ( $is_longest_period && $is_longest_interval ) {
$is_min = true;
// Longest with a new billing period
} elseif ( $is_longest_period && $variation_data['subscription']['period'] !== $variable_subscription_trial_period ) {
$is_min = true;
}
}
// Otherwise the cheapest variation is the one with the longer trial
} elseif ( $variable_subscription_trial_period === $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) {
$is_min = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] > $variable_subscription_trial_length;
// Otherwise just a longer trial period (that isn't equal to the longest period)
} elseif ( wcs_get_longest_period( $longest_trial_period, $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) === $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) {
$is_min = true;
}
if ( $is_min ) {
$longest_trial_period = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'];
$longest_trial_length = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'];
}
// If the current cheapest variation is also free, then the shortest trial period is the most expensive
if ( 0 == $lowest_price || '' === $lowest_price ) {
if ( '' === $shortest_trial_period ) {
$is_max = true;
// Need to check trial length
} elseif ( $shortest_trial_period === $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) {
$is_max = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] < $shortest_trial_length;
// Need to find shortest period
} elseif ( wcs_get_shortest_period( $shortest_trial_period, $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) === $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) {
$is_max = true;
}
if ( $is_max ) {
$shortest_trial_period = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'];
$shortest_trial_length = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'];
}
}
} else {
$longest_initial_period = wcs_get_longest_period( $longest_initial_period, $initial_period );
$shortest_initial_period = wcs_get_shortest_period( $shortest_initial_period, $initial_period );
$is_lowest_initial_amount = $initial_amount < $lowest_initial_amount || '' === $lowest_initial_amount;
$is_longest_initial_period = $initial_period === $longest_initial_period;
$is_longest_initial_interval = $initial_interval >= $longest_initial_interval || '' === $longest_initial_interval;
$is_highest_initial = $initial_amount > $highest_initial_amount || '' === $highest_initial_amount;
$is_shortest_period = $initial_period === $shortest_initial_period || '' === $shortest_initial_period;
$is_shortest_interval = $initial_interval < $shortest_initial_interval || '' === $shortest_initial_interval;
// If we're not dealing with the lowest initial access amount, then ignore this variation
if ( ! $is_lowest_initial_amount && $initial_amount !== $lowest_initial_amount ) {
continue;
}
// If the variation has the lowest price, it's the cheapest
if ( $is_lowest_initial_amount ) {
$is_min = true;
// When current variation's price is the same as the lowest, it's the cheapest only if it has a longer billing schedule
} elseif ( $initial_amount === $lowest_initial_amount ) {
// We need to check the recurring schedule when the sign-up fee & free trial periods are equal
if ( $has_free_trial && $initial_period == $longest_initial_period && $initial_interval == $longest_initial_interval ) {
// If the variation has the lowest recurring price, it's the cheapest
if ( $is_lowest_price ) {
$is_min = true;
// When current variation's price is the same as the lowest, it's the cheapest only if it has a longer billing schedule
} elseif ( $variation_data['price'] === $lowest_price ) {
if ( $is_longest_period && $is_longest_interval ) {
$is_min = true;
// Longest with a new billing period
} elseif ( $is_longest_period && $variation_data['subscription']['period'] !== $variable_subscription_period ) {
$is_min = true;
}
}
// Longest initial term is the cheapest
} elseif ( $is_longest_initial_period && $is_longest_initial_interval ) {
$is_min = true;
// Longest with a new billing period
} elseif ( $is_longest_initial_period && $initial_period !== $variable_subscription_period ) {
$is_min = true;
}
}
// If we have the highest price for the shortest period, we might have the maximum variation
if ( $is_highest_initial && $is_shortest_period && $is_shortest_interval ) {
$is_max = true;
// But only if its for the shortest billing period
} elseif ( $variation_data['price'] === $highest_price ) {
if ( $is_shortest_period && $is_shortest_interval ) {
$is_max = true;
} elseif ( $is_shortest_period ) {
$is_max = true;
}
}
}
// If it's the min subscription terms
if ( $is_min ) {
$min_variation_id = $variation_id;
$lowest_price = $variation_data['price'];
$lowest_regular_price = $variation_data['regular_price'];
$lowest_sale_price = $variation_data['sale_price'];
$lowest_regular_price = ( '' === $lowest_regular_price ) ? 0 : $lowest_regular_price;
$lowest_sale_price = ( '' === $lowest_sale_price ) ? 0 : $lowest_sale_price;
$lowest_initial_amount = $initial_amount;
$longest_initial_period = $initial_period;
$longest_initial_interval = $initial_interval;
$variable_subscription_sign_up_fee = $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'];
$variable_subscription_period = $variation_data['subscription']['period'];
$variable_subscription_period_interval = $variation_data['subscription']['interval'];
$variable_subscription_trial_length = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'];
$variable_subscription_trial_period = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'];
$variable_subscription_length = $variation_data['subscription']['length'];
}
if ( $is_max ) {
$max_variation_id = $variation_id;
$highest_price = $variation_data['price'];
$highest_regular_price = $variation_data['regular_price'];
$highest_sale_price = $variation_data['sale_price'];
$highest_initial_amount = $initial_amount;
$highest_regular_price = ( '' === $highest_regular_price ) ? 0 : $highest_regular_price;
$highest_sale_price = ( '' === $highest_sale_price ) ? 0 : $highest_sale_price;
$max_subscription_period = $variation_data['subscription']['period'];
$max_subscription_period_interval = $variation_data['subscription']['interval'];
}
}
if ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_prices_list ) ) > 1 ) {
$subscription_details_identical = false;
} elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_sign_up_fees_list ) ) > 1 ) {
$subscription_details_identical = false;
} elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_periods_list ) ) > 1 ) {
$subscription_details_identical = false;
} elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_intervals_list ) ) > 1 ) {
$subscription_details_identical = false;
} elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_trial_lengths_list ) ) > 1 ) {
$subscription_details_identical = false;
} elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_trial_periods_list ) ) > 1 ) {
$subscription_details_identical = false;
} elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_lengths_list ) ) > 1 ) {
$subscription_details_identical = false;
} else {
$subscription_details_identical = true;
}
return array(
'min' => array(
'variation_id' => $min_variation_id,
'price' => $lowest_price,
'regular_price' => $lowest_regular_price,
'sale_price' => $lowest_sale_price,
'period' => $variable_subscription_period,
'interval' => $variable_subscription_period_interval,
),
'max' => array(
'variation_id' => $max_variation_id,
'price' => $highest_price,
'regular_price' => $highest_regular_price,
'sale_price' => $highest_sale_price,
'period' => $max_subscription_period,
'interval' => $max_subscription_period_interval,
),
'subscription' => array(
'signup-fee' => $variable_subscription_sign_up_fee,
'trial_period' => $variable_subscription_trial_period,
'trial_length' => $variable_subscription_trial_length,
'length' => $variable_subscription_length,
),
'identical' => $subscription_details_identical,
);
}
/**
* Generates a key for grouping subscription products with the same billing schedule.
*
* Used in a frontend cart and checkout context to group items by a recurring cart key for use in generating recurring carts.
* Used by the orders/
Cost Of Living Index Shows Odessa Below National Averages is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>Each quarter The Council gathers information from 274 urban areas. Locally, the Odessa Development Corporation (ODC) helps gather and submit the data for Odessa. The composite index is based on six component categories – housing, utilities, grocery items, transportation, health care, and miscellaneous goods and services.

In addition to an overall cost of goods and services, each quarter the index focuses on particular areas of interest for a deeper dive. For the second quarter 2023 survey the index focused on two detail areas: grocery costs and appliance repair costs. In terms of food cost Odessa ranked just below the average at 97.5%.

Odessa residents placed exactly at the average for appliance repair costs while Midland, interestingly, placed higher at 110 meaning that, on average, it cost more to get an appliance repaired in Midland than in Odessa.

Odessa Development Corporation President Kris Crow stated “It’s important to gather this information on our local cost of living because this is something that companies looking to relocate or expand to Odessa are interested in. While it sometimes seems that the prices in Odessa are high the reality is that Odessa is well positioned below the national averages and this creates a favorable environment for companies who are concerned about their employee’s cost of living.”
Cost Of Living Index Shows Odessa Below National Averages is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>ODC Attempts to “Backdate” Nacero Contract is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>Listed as agenda item number five is an item to award Nacero its first payment under an economic development grant inked between Nacero and ODC in June of 2021. Under terms of the agreement, Nacero must complete at least $100 million dollars of investment in the Penwell facility during year one of the agreement with subsequent awards in years two through five requiring $1 billion per year investment in the Penwell project.
Groundbreaking on the Penwell plant was originally planned for fall of 2021 and was later pushed to January or February of 2022 and then again to spring of 2022 reportedly due to difficulties in scheduling Texas Governor Gregg Abbott to participate. Later reports indicated that the groundbreaking was further delayed due to the difficulties being experienced by Nacero in obtaining all of the financing commitments required to proceed with the project. Nacero has still not broken ground on the proposed facility.
A review of the Nacero compliance audit completed for ODC by the Weaver accounting firm indicates that in order to meet the $100 million grant threshold it would be necessary to allow Nacero to include all costs related to their proposed plant since its inception in 2018 although the ODC agreement wasn’t inked until June of 2021. Even including all costs incurred since 2018, the investment falls short and is listed as $99,578,400.
“There are a number of aspects of the current grant request that I find troubling” stated ODC Board Member Kris Crow. “First is that this grant request was not vetted by the ODC Compliance Committee which would be normal operating procedure. While I have often been a critic of the Compliance Committee, current protocol is that all grant requests must be reviewed by the Compliance Committee before being presented to the ODC Board and I am unaware of any project that hasn’t been required to take this step through Compliance before being listed on our agenda for approval.” The ODC Compliance Committee is a review and audit group that verifies and certifies the information presented by grant recipients.
“Second, in order to meet the grant requirements of a $100 million dollar investment it appears that Nacero was allowed to go back to day one of their project design instead of the contract requirement of year one – June 2021 to June 2022 – investment in the Odessa facility. I have never been aware of allowing a company to essentially backdate their investment requirement and it is unclear to me how much of these expenses are attributable to the Penwell facility.” further stated Crow.
A search of news articles shows that Nacero originally proposed to build a $3 billion dollar natural gas to gasoline plant in Casa Grande, Arizona in March 0f 2020. This plant which was promised to create 2,000 construction jobs and 265 high paying permanent jobs was permanently halted in November of 2020 as Nucero “reprioritized its projects”.
In June of 2021 Nacero announced the Penwell project which was originally promised to provide a six to seven billion dollar construction cost infusion into the local economy and create hundreds of high paying permanent jobs.
Also reported was an effort by the Mohave Arizona County Board of Supervisors in June 0f 2021 to increase the incentives for Nacero to build a plant in the Kingman area of Mohave County which was also promised to create 2,500 construction jobs and 400 permanent high paying jobs.
In January, 2022 the Bay Journal reported that Nacero was seeking $6.7 million per year in incentives to build a 3,000 acre plant in Luzerne County, PA on the site of an abandoned coal plant. According to local news reports a coalition of 16 local and statewide environmental groups opposed the project saying there was no evidence to back up Nacero’s claims of large carbon-footprint reductions with the use of Nacero’s gasoline.
“In light of the various projects announced by Nacero across the United States, I am concerned that Odessa taxpayers are being asked to subsidize the work being done on proposed plant locations outside of Ector County. This would be totally contrary to ODC’s mandate to fund only projects in Ector County.” stated Crow. “As it stands right now I will be asking for a breakdown on the investment made by Nacero in the Penwell project since ODC signed our agreement in June of 2021 as these are the only expenses that would be eligible under the terms of our agreement.”
In a closing footnote, The Weaver compliance review report notes that “the majority of the investment reported for year one of the EDA (Economic Development Agreement) was incurred prior to the start of the EDA agreement period.”
Previous reports made by Nacero to ODC Members and members of the Odessa City Council have indicated that Nacero has been unable to arrange all of the financing required to start construction and that the project has been hampered by the uncertain construction costs due to the currently high US inflation rate.
Odessa Headlines reached out to ODC Chairperson David Boutin for comment but as of press time Boutin had not responded.
ODC Attempts to “Backdate” Nacero Contract is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>Nacero Announces Major Changes During ODC Meeting is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>Hal Bouknight, Chief Operating Officer of Nacero, presented ODC a number of significant changes to the construction plans of the world’s first natural gas to gasoline plant in western Ector County.
The plant which will cost a total of $6-8 billion dollars is described as a transitional fuel manufacturing facility that will produce millions of gallons of cleaner-burning, sulfur-free fuels that can be used in existing trucks and automobiles with no conversion or changes to the vehicle. Nacero’s plant will also be net carbon-zero as all CO2 produced will be captured and recycled for recovery operations in the oilfield and other uses.
Originally expected to be built by Bechtel – a huge multi-national company that specializes in building large industrial facilities around the world – the plant will now be built in phases by a combination of local and state-wide companies. Mr. Bouknight stated that this plan will provide greater local economic impact as well as lower costs and a faster time to market.
Bouknight described several milestones met by the company to make the Nacero plant a reality including closing on the plant’s site near Penwell, striking deals with all mineral rights owners in the area, and securing agreements with local natural gas suppliers for the feedstock for the plant. Nacero has also obtained the necessary Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ) permits necessary to begin construction on the plant.
Required environmental remediation work on the site is predicted to begin quickly and Boukman is projecting that a groundbreaking ceremony will be held in late January or early February.
In other action, the ODC received several subcontractor reports and voted to table an economic development request from Rhodes USA, which is seeking to build a cold-formed steel manufacturing plant in the area to supply pre-engineered wall framing units to local builders.
Rhodes USA supplied some additional requested documentation regarding projected payroll numbers to the ODC compliance committee only a few days before the ODC meeting and the compliance committee didn’t have time to review the new information stated ODC Chair Tim Edgemon who requested the issue be tabled.
Also tabled was a final grant payment to Select Energy. Following the review of the company, officials with ODC requested additional information to verify Select Energy’s payroll numbers and the Assistant City Manager of Administrative Services Cindy Muncy indicated that questions had arisen during a review of the agreement.
Edgemon moved repeatedly to table the item, but the table motion was objected to by ODC member Chris Cole who questioned why the motion was being requested since the request had been approved by both Weaver and Tidwell, the ODC’s compliance review firm, and the ODC compliance committee.
A discussion ensued but the motion to table was finally approved by ODC, directing that the Select Energy proposal be sent back to Weaver and Tidwell, as well as the ODC compliance committee for further review.
The next item on the agenda was also tabled.
At issue was the renewal and extension of the ODC’s contract with Weaver and Tidwell for compliance auditing services and in light of some issues uncovered with the Select Energy request, ODC members quickly moved to table the item.
The next meeting of the Odessa Development Council is scheduled for December 9, 2021, at 2:00 PM in the Odessa City Council Chambers.
Nacero Announces Major Changes During ODC Meeting is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>Odessa Economic Development Official Raises Open Meetings Act Concern is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>Odessa Headlines recently reported on an appointment vote to fill a vacancy on the ODC subcommittee, called the “compliance committee”, that was conducted by secret ballot in violation of the OMA.
It was in the May 13 meeting that a new vote was taken to “cure” the illegal appointment of former city councilwoman Peggy Dean, that ODC board member Kris Crow raised concern that the compliance committee itself, may be operating in violation of open meetings requirements.
Dean was appointed in a 4-3 public vote.
According to city officials, the 10-person compliance committee routinely does the bulk of the work reviewing and negotiating economic incentive packages that it then submits to the ODC board for review. From there, the ODC board can either alter the proposal further, send it back to the compliance committee, or send the proposal up to the city council for approval.
Unlike the ODC board and city council, however, the compliance committee operates behind closed doors in total secrecy – with no public meetings, agendas, or minutes, and any four of the members constitutes a quorum necessary to put a proposal together.
In raising his concerns with open meetings laws, Crow pointed to a handbook published by the Texas Attorney General’s Offices on OMA guidelines, citing what it says regarding committees that are exempt only when they do not control or supervise the public business and have the proposals routinely approved.
“I think we can agree compliance has a lot of control over what ODC does as they come in and put together our packages even help negotiate what the offers are going to be and bring us the final package” Crow stated, adding further “If someone can make the argument that we routinely approve what they bring us they could be in violation of the OMA act.”
ODC board member Melanie Hollman fired back at Crow, saying she disagrees with Crow’s assessment.
“I don’t believe that there’s a good argument that we rubber-stamp what the compliance committee does, I don’t think that’s accurate at all. This body has regularly, and even with your prior term here with the board, changed or made a change to whatever compliance recommendation… or even negated what compliance recommended” Hollman said.
Hollman went on to explain that one main reason compliance is exempt from the OMA is because they do not make any binding decisions.
“The most important reason for them to do what they do is that companies that come to us are not interested in revealing their trade secret information and compliance can meet and keep that information private”, Hollman added.
Crow responded by saying that sensitive information could be discussed in executive session, and further emphasized his point that this could be another end-run around the OMA.
Board member Chris Cole then joined in the conversation, saying if Crow’s concerns are legal then they should have the city legal department review whether or not compliance is operating within the open meetings act, to which the entire board appeared to agree.
Odessa Headlines spoke with an Austin-based attorney who is an expert in Open Meeting Act issues, who stated that when committee see their recommendations routinely approved by the board, they can become subject to the Open Meetings Act.
A quick review of two years of meeting minutes for the Odessa City Council and the Odessa Economic Development Board failed to turn up evidence of when the last compliance committee recommendation was altered or rejected by the ODC board.
Odessa Headlines will continue to review whether the board “routinely” approves, or “rubber stamps” the compliance committee’s recommendations and whether the committee is complying with state laws regarding open meetings.
Editor’s note: It is the policy of Odessa Headlines that open government is the best form of government. While acknowledging the need for government to address a limited number of issues privately, issues regarding the public’s business should always be as open and accessible to the people as possible.
Odessa Economic Development Official Raises Open Meetings Act Concern is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>Odessa Economic Development Board to Redo Appointment Vote is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>At issue was an agenda item to consider and vote on an appointment to fill a vacancy in the compliance committee – an important 14-member advisory committee tasked with making sure requests for public funding comply with the law, as well as making funding proposals.
The proposals compliance puts forward are then routinely approved by both the ODC board, and then the city council.
Multiple applicants had filled out applications to be considered for the position.
However, several witnesses tell Odessa Headlines that when the agenda item came up for consideration, rather than adhere to the regular meeting process, board Chairman Tim Edgmon instructed the secretary to distribute paper ballots among the board members, who then voted by paper ballot to make the appointment – ultimately concealing how each board member voted.
After the board secretary gathered and tabulated the results, it was announced that former At-Large City Councilmember Peggy Dean was the winner of the appointment vote.
Odessa Headlines spoke with multiple members of the ODC board, including Jeff Russell, who was recently appointed to the board by At-Large City Councilmember Denise Swanner.
Russell stated that he was surprised when the vote happened and regretted not objecting, however, since it was his first meeting on the board and other seasoned members didn’t seem concerned, he wasn’t quite sure what to do.
“To be honest it caught me off guard and happened so quickly. I was looking forward to the opportunity to discuss the applicants in the meeting, but as a consequence of the voting procedure – by written ballot – I was not given that opportunity” Russell stated, adding further “One thing is for sure – now that I have a meeting under my belt I will quicker in asking questions.”
Odessa Headlines emailed board chairman Tim Edgmon who presided over the meeting, asking whether there was, in fact, a vote by secret ballot, and if so, how would it comply with the Open Meetings Act, and asked if the board had ever voted by secret ballot before?
Edgmon responded, confirming to Odessa Headlines that there was a vote by ballot, but stopped short of calling it a “secret ballot” and also stated they will have a redo vote on the appointment at the next meeting, and that as for now, there is still a vacancy on compliance committee.
“There aren’t many procedural rules for the OMA. We followed the procedures outlined in the Act by properly posting and keeping minutes of the meeting. The final action of appointing a new member to the Compliance Committee was taken in an open meeting. The applications were sent to board members in advance. Because the date and time of the ODC meeting changed and we needed to be out of the Council Chambers for the TIRZ meeting, I thought having a ballot would expedite the vote. Board members always have the option to ask for discussion on an item. We will take a vote on this item at the next regularly scheduled ODC meeting. At this time, there is still one vacancy on the Compliance Committee,” Edgmon wrote in his response.
Edgmon also confirmed that the ODC board has voted by “ballot” before but didn’t say how often or on what issues.
According to the Open Meetings Act manual published by the Texas Attorney General, final votes taken by governmental entities subject to the OMA like the ODC “may not vote in an open session by secret written ballot.”
Once the ODC board holds a new vote on the compliance committee appointment, the appointee will be finally able to participate in board activities. It is unclear when the next ODC board meeting will be held.
Odessa Economic Development Board to Redo Appointment Vote is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.
]]>