1, 'price' => $product->get_price(), ) ); if ( function_exists( 'wc_get_price_including_tax' ) ) { // WC 3.0+ $price = wc_get_price_including_tax( $product, $args ); } else { // WC < 3.0 $price = $product->get_price_including_tax( $args['qty'], $args['price'] ); } return $price; } /** * For a given product, and optionally price/qty, work out the sign-up fee with tax excluded, based on store settings. * * @since 1.0.0 - Migrated from WooCommerce Subscriptions v2.2.0 * @param WC_Product $product * @param array $args * @return float */ function wcs_get_price_excluding_tax( $product, $args = array() ) { $args = wp_parse_args( $args, array( 'qty' => 1, 'price' => $product->get_price(), ) ); if ( function_exists( 'wc_get_price_excluding_tax' ) ) { // WC 3.0+ $price = wc_get_price_excluding_tax( $product, $args ); } else { // WC < 3.0 $price = $product->get_price_excluding_tax( $args['qty'], $args['price'] ); } return $price; } /** * Returns a 'from' prefix if you want to show where prices start at. * * @since 1.0.0 - Migrated from WooCommerce Subscriptions v2.2.0 * @return string */ function wcs_get_price_html_from_text( $product = '' ) { if ( function_exists( 'wc_get_price_html_from_text' ) ) { // WC 3.0+ $price_html_from_text = wc_get_price_html_from_text(); } else { // WC < 3.0 $price_html_from_text = $product->get_price_html_from_text(); } return $price_html_from_text; } /** * Get an array of the prices, used to help determine min/max values. * * @since 1.0.0 - Migrated from WooCommerce Subscriptions v2.2.0 */ function wcs_get_variation_prices( $variation, $variable_product ) { return array( 'price' => apply_filters( 'woocommerce_variation_prices_price', WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_price( $variation ), $variation, $variable_product ), 'regular_price' => apply_filters( 'woocommerce_variation_prices_regular_price', WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_regular_price( $variation, 'edit' ), $variation, $variable_product ), 'sale_price' => apply_filters( 'woocommerce_variation_prices_sale_price', WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_sale_price( $variation, 'edit' ), $variation, $variable_product ), 'sign_up_fee' => apply_filters( 'woocommerce_variation_prices_sign_up_fee', WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_sign_up_fee( $variation ), $variation, $variable_product ), ); } /** * Get an array of the minimum and maximum priced variations based on subscription billing terms. * * @param array $child_variation_ids the IDs of product variation children ids * @return array Array containing the min and max variation prices and billing data * @since 1.0.0 - Migrated from WooCommerce Subscriptions v2.2.0 */ function wcs_get_min_max_variation_data( $variable_product, $child_variation_ids = array() ) { if ( empty( $child_variation_ids ) ) { $child_variation_ids = is_callable( array( $variable_product, 'get_visible_children' ) ) ? $variable_product->get_visible_children() : $variable_product->get_children( true ); } $variations_data = array(); foreach ( $child_variation_ids as $variation_id ) { if ( $variation = wc_get_product( $variation_id ) ) { $prices = wcs_get_variation_prices( $variation, $variable_product ); foreach ( $prices as $price_key => $amount ) { if ( '' !== $amount ) { if ( 'incl' === get_option( 'woocommerce_tax_display_shop' ) ) { $prices[ $price_key ] = wcs_get_price_including_tax( $variable_product, array( 'price' => $amount ) ); } else { $prices[ $price_key ] = wcs_get_price_excluding_tax( $variable_product, array( 'price' => $amount ) ); } } } $variations_data[ $variation_id ] = array( 'price' => $prices['price'], 'regular_price' => $prices['regular_price'], 'sale_price' => $prices['sale_price'], 'subscription' => array( 'sign_up_fee' => $prices['sign_up_fee'], 'period' => WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_period( $variation ), 'interval' => WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_interval( $variation ), 'trial_length' => WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_trial_length( $variation ), 'trial_period' => WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_trial_period( $variation ), 'length' => WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_length( $variation ), ), ); } } return wcs_calculate_min_max_variations( $variations_data ); } /** * Determine the minimum and maximum values for a set of structured subscription * price data in a form created by @see wcs_get_min_max_variation_data() * * @param array $variations_data the IDs of product variation children ids * @return array * @since 1.0.0 - Migrated from WooCommerce Subscriptions v2.2.0 */ function wcs_calculate_min_max_variations( $variations_data ) { $lowest_initial_amount = $highest_initial_amount = $lowest_price = $highest_price = ''; $shortest_initial_period = $longest_initial_period = $shortest_trial_period = $longest_trial_period = $shortest_trial_length = $longest_trial_length = ''; $longest_initial_interval = $shortest_initial_interval = $variable_subscription_period = $variable_subscription_period_interval = ''; $lowest_regular_price = $highest_regular_price = $lowest_sale_price = $highest_sale_price = $max_subscription_period = $max_subscription_period_interval = ''; $variable_subscription_sign_up_fee = $variable_subscription_trial_period = $variable_subscription_trial_length = $variable_subscription_length = $variable_subscription_sign_up_fee = $variable_subscription_trial_period = $variable_subscription_trial_length = $variable_subscription_length = ''; $min_variation_id = $max_variation_id = null; $variations_data_prices_list = array(); $variations_data_sign_up_fees_list = array(); $variations_data_periods_list = array(); $variations_data_intervals_list = array(); $variations_data_trial_lengths_list = array(); $variations_data_trial_periods_list = array(); $variations_data_lengths_list = array(); foreach ( $variations_data as $variation_id => $variation_data ) { $is_max = $is_min = false; if ( '' === $variation_data['price'] && empty( $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'] ) ) { continue; } $variations_data_prices_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_prices_list, array( $variation_data['price'] ) ) ); $variations_data_sign_up_fees_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_sign_up_fees_list, array( empty( $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'] ) ? 0 : $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'] ) ) ); $variations_data_periods_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_periods_list, array( $variation_data['subscription']['period'] ) ) ); $variations_data_intervals_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_intervals_list, array( $variation_data['subscription']['interval'] ) ) ); $variations_data_trial_lengths_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_trial_lengths_list, array( empty( $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] ) ? 0 : $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] ) ) ); $variations_data_trial_periods_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_trial_periods_list, array( $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) ) ); $variations_data_lengths_list = array_unique( array_merge( $variations_data_lengths_list, array( $variation_data['subscription']['length'] ) ) ); $has_free_trial = '' !== $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] && $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] > 0; // Determine some recurring price flags $is_lowest_price = $variation_data['price'] < $lowest_price || '' === $lowest_price; $is_longest_period = wcs_get_longest_period( $variable_subscription_period, $variation_data['subscription']['period'] ) === $variation_data['subscription']['period']; $is_longest_interval = $variation_data['subscription']['interval'] >= $variable_subscription_period_interval || '' === $variable_subscription_period_interval; // Find the amount the subscriber will have to pay up-front if ( $has_free_trial ) { $initial_amount = $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee']; $initial_period = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period']; $initial_interval = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length']; } else { $initial_amount = (float) $variation_data['price'] + (float) $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee']; $initial_period = $variation_data['subscription']['period']; $initial_interval = $variation_data['subscription']['interval']; } // We have a free trial & no sign-up fee, so need to choose the longest free trial (and maybe the shortest) if ( $has_free_trial && 0 == $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee'] ) { // First variation if ( '' === $longest_trial_period ) { $is_min = true; // If two variations have the same free trial, choose the variation with the lowest recurring price for the longest period } elseif ( $variable_subscription_trial_period === $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] && $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] === $variable_subscription_trial_length ) { // If the variation has the lowest recurring price, it's the cheapest if ( $is_lowest_price ) { $is_min = true; // When current variation's free trial is the same as the lowest, it's the cheaper if it has a longer billing schedule } elseif ( $variation_data['price'] === $lowest_price ) { if ( $is_longest_period && $is_longest_interval ) { $is_min = true; // Longest with a new billing period } elseif ( $is_longest_period && $variation_data['subscription']['period'] !== $variable_subscription_trial_period ) { $is_min = true; } } // Otherwise the cheapest variation is the one with the longer trial } elseif ( $variable_subscription_trial_period === $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) { $is_min = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] > $variable_subscription_trial_length; // Otherwise just a longer trial period (that isn't equal to the longest period) } elseif ( wcs_get_longest_period( $longest_trial_period, $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) === $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) { $is_min = true; } if ( $is_min ) { $longest_trial_period = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period']; $longest_trial_length = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length']; } // If the current cheapest variation is also free, then the shortest trial period is the most expensive if ( 0 == $lowest_price || '' === $lowest_price ) { if ( '' === $shortest_trial_period ) { $is_max = true; // Need to check trial length } elseif ( $shortest_trial_period === $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) { $is_max = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length'] < $shortest_trial_length; // Need to find shortest period } elseif ( wcs_get_shortest_period( $shortest_trial_period, $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) === $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period'] ) { $is_max = true; } if ( $is_max ) { $shortest_trial_period = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period']; $shortest_trial_length = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length']; } } } else { $longest_initial_period = wcs_get_longest_period( $longest_initial_period, $initial_period ); $shortest_initial_period = wcs_get_shortest_period( $shortest_initial_period, $initial_period ); $is_lowest_initial_amount = $initial_amount < $lowest_initial_amount || '' === $lowest_initial_amount; $is_longest_initial_period = $initial_period === $longest_initial_period; $is_longest_initial_interval = $initial_interval >= $longest_initial_interval || '' === $longest_initial_interval; $is_highest_initial = $initial_amount > $highest_initial_amount || '' === $highest_initial_amount; $is_shortest_period = $initial_period === $shortest_initial_period || '' === $shortest_initial_period; $is_shortest_interval = $initial_interval < $shortest_initial_interval || '' === $shortest_initial_interval; // If we're not dealing with the lowest initial access amount, then ignore this variation if ( ! $is_lowest_initial_amount && $initial_amount !== $lowest_initial_amount ) { continue; } // If the variation has the lowest price, it's the cheapest if ( $is_lowest_initial_amount ) { $is_min = true; // When current variation's price is the same as the lowest, it's the cheapest only if it has a longer billing schedule } elseif ( $initial_amount === $lowest_initial_amount ) { // We need to check the recurring schedule when the sign-up fee & free trial periods are equal if ( $has_free_trial && $initial_period == $longest_initial_period && $initial_interval == $longest_initial_interval ) { // If the variation has the lowest recurring price, it's the cheapest if ( $is_lowest_price ) { $is_min = true; // When current variation's price is the same as the lowest, it's the cheapest only if it has a longer billing schedule } elseif ( $variation_data['price'] === $lowest_price ) { if ( $is_longest_period && $is_longest_interval ) { $is_min = true; // Longest with a new billing period } elseif ( $is_longest_period && $variation_data['subscription']['period'] !== $variable_subscription_period ) { $is_min = true; } } // Longest initial term is the cheapest } elseif ( $is_longest_initial_period && $is_longest_initial_interval ) { $is_min = true; // Longest with a new billing period } elseif ( $is_longest_initial_period && $initial_period !== $variable_subscription_period ) { $is_min = true; } } // If we have the highest price for the shortest period, we might have the maximum variation if ( $is_highest_initial && $is_shortest_period && $is_shortest_interval ) { $is_max = true; // But only if its for the shortest billing period } elseif ( $variation_data['price'] === $highest_price ) { if ( $is_shortest_period && $is_shortest_interval ) { $is_max = true; } elseif ( $is_shortest_period ) { $is_max = true; } } } // If it's the min subscription terms if ( $is_min ) { $min_variation_id = $variation_id; $lowest_price = $variation_data['price']; $lowest_regular_price = $variation_data['regular_price']; $lowest_sale_price = $variation_data['sale_price']; $lowest_regular_price = ( '' === $lowest_regular_price ) ? 0 : $lowest_regular_price; $lowest_sale_price = ( '' === $lowest_sale_price ) ? 0 : $lowest_sale_price; $lowest_initial_amount = $initial_amount; $longest_initial_period = $initial_period; $longest_initial_interval = $initial_interval; $variable_subscription_sign_up_fee = $variation_data['subscription']['sign_up_fee']; $variable_subscription_period = $variation_data['subscription']['period']; $variable_subscription_period_interval = $variation_data['subscription']['interval']; $variable_subscription_trial_length = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_length']; $variable_subscription_trial_period = $variation_data['subscription']['trial_period']; $variable_subscription_length = $variation_data['subscription']['length']; } if ( $is_max ) { $max_variation_id = $variation_id; $highest_price = $variation_data['price']; $highest_regular_price = $variation_data['regular_price']; $highest_sale_price = $variation_data['sale_price']; $highest_initial_amount = $initial_amount; $highest_regular_price = ( '' === $highest_regular_price ) ? 0 : $highest_regular_price; $highest_sale_price = ( '' === $highest_sale_price ) ? 0 : $highest_sale_price; $max_subscription_period = $variation_data['subscription']['period']; $max_subscription_period_interval = $variation_data['subscription']['interval']; } } if ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_prices_list ) ) > 1 ) { $subscription_details_identical = false; } elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_sign_up_fees_list ) ) > 1 ) { $subscription_details_identical = false; } elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_periods_list ) ) > 1 ) { $subscription_details_identical = false; } elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_intervals_list ) ) > 1 ) { $subscription_details_identical = false; } elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_trial_lengths_list ) ) > 1 ) { $subscription_details_identical = false; } elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_trial_periods_list ) ) > 1 ) { $subscription_details_identical = false; } elseif ( sizeof( array_unique( $variations_data_lengths_list ) ) > 1 ) { $subscription_details_identical = false; } else { $subscription_details_identical = true; } return array( 'min' => array( 'variation_id' => $min_variation_id, 'price' => $lowest_price, 'regular_price' => $lowest_regular_price, 'sale_price' => $lowest_sale_price, 'period' => $variable_subscription_period, 'interval' => $variable_subscription_period_interval, ), 'max' => array( 'variation_id' => $max_variation_id, 'price' => $highest_price, 'regular_price' => $highest_regular_price, 'sale_price' => $highest_sale_price, 'period' => $max_subscription_period, 'interval' => $max_subscription_period_interval, ), 'subscription' => array( 'signup-fee' => $variable_subscription_sign_up_fee, 'trial_period' => $variable_subscription_trial_period, 'trial_length' => $variable_subscription_trial_length, 'length' => $variable_subscription_length, ), 'identical' => $subscription_details_identical, ); } /** * Generates a key for grouping subscription products with the same billing schedule. * * Used in a frontend cart and checkout context to group items by a recurring cart key for use in generating recurring carts. * Used by the orders//subscriptions REST API endpoint to group order items into subscriptions. * * @see https://woocommerce.com/document/subscriptions/develop/multiple-subscriptions/#section-3 * * @param WC_Product $product The product to generate the key for. * @param int $renewal_time The timestamp of the first renewal payment. * * @return string The subscription product grouping key. */ function wcs_get_subscription_grouping_key( $product, $renewal_time = 0 ) { $key = ''; $renewal_time = ! empty( $renewal_time ) ? $renewal_time : WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_first_renewal_payment_time( $product ); $interval = WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_interval( $product ); $period = WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_period( $product ); $length = WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_length( $product ); $trial_period = WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_trial_period( $product ); $trial_length = WC_Subscriptions_Product::get_trial_length( $product ); if ( $renewal_time > 0 ) { $key .= gmdate( 'Y_m_d_', $renewal_time ); } // First start with the billing interval and period. switch ( $interval ) { case 1: if ( 'day' === $period ) { $key .= 'daily'; } else { $key .= sprintf( '%sly', $period ); } break; case 2: $key .= sprintf( 'every_2nd_%s', $period ); break; case 3: $key .= sprintf( 'every_3rd_%s', $period ); // or sometimes two exceptions it would seem break; default: $key .= sprintf( 'every_%dth_%s', $interval, $period ); break; } if ( $length > 0 ) { $key .= '_for_'; $key .= sprintf( '%d_%s', $length, $period ); if ( $length > 1 ) { $key .= 's'; } } if ( $trial_length > 0 ) { $key .= sprintf( '_after_a_%d_%s_trial', $trial_length, $trial_period ); } return apply_filters( 'wcs_subscription_product_grouping_key', $key, $product, $renewal_time ); } ECISD Archives - Odessa Headlines https://odessaheadlines.com/category/education/ecisd-education/ Covering Ector County, Texas Wed, 08 Nov 2023 15:42:29 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.5 https://odessaheadlines.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/cropped-MAR21-Odessa-Icon-150x150.png ECISD Archives - Odessa Headlines https://odessaheadlines.com/category/education/ecisd-education/ 32 32 ECISD Proposition A Passes By Wide Margin https://odessaheadlines.com/2023/11/08/ecisd-proposition-a-passes-by-wide-margin/ Wed, 08 Nov 2023 15:42:26 +0000 https://odessaheadlines.com/?p=2287 Ector County voters went to the polls Tuesday to vote on a number of State Constitutional amendments as well as three ECISD bond proposals. By a 57% to 43% margin Ector County voters approved the largest ever school bond proposal of almost $450,000,000. Notably, this bond will be used to fund the construction of a […]

ECISD Proposition A Passes By Wide Margin is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
Ector County voters went to the polls Tuesday to vote on a number of State Constitutional amendments as well as three ECISD bond proposals.

By a 57% to 43% margin Ector County voters approved the largest ever school bond proposal of almost $450,000,000. Notably, this bond will be used to fund the construction of a new career and technical center as well as a new middle school in west Ector County and fund $120,000,000 in maintenance and repairs to existing campuses. Two other proposals regarding Ratliff Stadium upgrades and indoor practice facilities at OHS and PHS failed.

This bond passage comes after two previous attempts failed. Prior to last night’s vote the last successful bond election was in 2012 when voters approved a plan to increase the size of Ector County’s two high school campuses and to realign ECISD schools to a ninth-twelfth grade high school configuration. The 2012 bond also included the construction of three new elementary schools.

“We’re proud that voters made their choice clearly known through the ballot box” stated Ector County Republican Party Chair Tisha Crow. “Now comes the hard part. During this election one of the major themes continued to be the issue of the voter’s lack of trust for our school district. As a Republican, I am proud of the fact that we were able to successfully elect two strong conservative Republican candidates – Wayne Woodall and Bob Thayer – to our school board in last May’s election and I think voters showed they were willing to give the newly constituted board the benefit of the doubt that they can overcome the many trust issues left behind by the old board. As conservatives, the ECRP will continue to press our school district to bring about the changes needed in our schools and to spend this money wisely. We strongly urge our Trustees to carry through on their promise to form a comprehensive bond oversight committee that will include the appointment of some of the critics of the just passed bond.”

ECISD Proposition A Passes By Wide Margin is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
ECISD Seems To Lack A Well Thought Out Plan https://odessaheadlines.com/2023/11/03/ecisd-seems-to-lack-a-well-thought-out-plan/ Fri, 03 Nov 2023 21:36:51 +0000 https://odessaheadlines.com/?p=2284 As I have researched ECISD over the past several months I have come to the conclusion that our school district does not have a well thought out plan for the future but rather seems to lurch from project to project, bond to bond, and idea to idea. Currently, we have three new school board members […]

ECISD Seems To Lack A Well Thought Out Plan is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
As I have researched ECISD over the past several months I have come to the conclusion that our school district does not have a well thought out plan for the future but rather seems to lurch from project to project, bond to bond, and idea to idea.

Currently, we have three new school board members who, with just a few months on the board and with no opportunity to fully understand the needs of our district, voted to move forward with the largest school bond ever proposed.  While I’m sure their intentions were right, it seems to me to be shortsighted of them to rush into a number of large and costly projects without first hand knowledge and understanding of the needs, the project management skills that will be required, and the overall school budget.  

Also, it would have seemed prudent to me for them to look at all of the resources our District currently has.  Probably most voters don’t know that ECISD currently owns twenty-six tracts of vacant land ranging in size from a few acres to 100 acres.  Many of these tracts are over 20 acres in size.  I wonder what, if any, use the district has for these sites or whether they should be sold off and the proceeds used to do some of the much needed repairs on our existing facilities.  We also have a number of current elementary school facilities that are operating at a fraction of their designed capacity.  

There has also been much discussion about student travel times and this has been a major driver of the current proposal for a far west middle school.  While I certainly agree with the sentiment that students shouldn’t have travel times that stretch into hours each day I have to stop and scratch my head about the announced location of the proposed career and technical center.  Voters will remember that in 2003 voters approved the building of the “Career Center” which is now New Tech.  This facility is located about as close to the center of Ector County as you could expect but it never lived up to its potential as a career training center.  For students located in Gardendale or west Ector County the newly proposed site will require lengthy travel times.

There is a seemingly endless list of other stops and starts by our district over the years.  We spent $906,203.00 to build greenhouses in 2021 to service 18 horticulture students that meet there for 2 hours a day.  Ector has been a high school, a middle school, a kind of magnet middle school, is now a charter school (which parents and students seem to like), and next year will go back to a regular middle school.  We currently own and run three teacher boarding houses and we have, year after year, run budget deficits – meaning we are going in the hole each year – which are gobbling up our rainy day fund balance that is meant to meet any potential emergencies – I hope and pray we don’t have another big hail storm with no money in bank to pay our deductibles.  We’re currently using some questionable financial tactics to try and tell voters that issuing almost half a billion dollars in new bonds isn’t going to cost us anything.

All of this dysfunction decreases student performance.  It is also costly and results in employee turnover.  Most voters are shocked when I tell them that over the past five years ECISD has lost 1,859 teachers and that we currently employ 150 international teachers that require some sort of sponsorship and that we have three transgender teachers in our ranks.

As voters head to the polls, I hope they ask themselves these simple questions as they decide whether or not to support this bond: 

  1. Do you believe that our school district has a well thought out plan for our district’s future?
  2. Do you think their current plans make sense for our community?
  3. Do you trust them to make sound and prudent decisions about how they will manage this bond money and our current school budget?

Shirley Kelley

ECISD Seems To Lack A Well Thought Out Plan is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
My Vote Against The 2023 ECISD Bond Comes Down To One Word: TRUST https://odessaheadlines.com/2023/10/19/my-vote-against-the-2023-ecisd-bond-comes-down-to-one-word-trust/ Thu, 19 Oct 2023 12:21:47 +0000 https://odessaheadlines.com/?p=2279 Ector County voters are once again faced with a massive ECISD bond on this November’s ballot- this one for almost half a billion dollars in total.  As Headlines readers know, I served on this bond committee as I have served on two previous bond committees.  While this proposed bond is much better designed than the […]

My Vote Against The 2023 ECISD Bond Comes Down To One Word: TRUST is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
Ector County voters are once again faced with a massive ECISD bond on this November’s ballot- this one for almost half a billion dollars in total.  As Headlines readers know, I served on this bond committee as I have served on two previous bond committees. 

While this proposed bond is much better designed than the failed 2022 bond I will still be voting against this proposal. 

Why? Because I simply don’t trust our school district to wisely spend the half billion dollars this election would pump into our school coffers to accomplish a large list of promised projects. 

During the District sponsored polling leading up to a previous bond the lack of trust voters had in our district emerged as the number one problem in getting voters to pass a bond. 

But wait, I have been told when recently voicing this lack of trust issue, ECISD has changed since then. New superintendent, several new board members – you can trust us now. This is the new and improved ECISD.

While I would love to believe this is true, a look at the facts shows that this self proclaimed new and improved ECISD acts and behaves a lot like the old and untrustworthy ECISD. 

TRUST ISSUE #1

In 2018 ECISD voters did something we had never done before: we voted to voluntarily raise our own school taxes by almost 13%. Because the State of Texas began capping the maximum school maintenance and operations tax (M&O) in an attempt to control runaway school property taxes ECISD was capped at at rate of $1.04. 

Following another failed bond election, ECISD put together a new bond committee which quickly realized voters had no stomach for another bond. I was on this committee. This bond committee morphed into the Tax Ratification Election or TRE Committee. Promising that this voluntary increase in taxes – which continues year after year – was critical to replace buses, pay the deductibles to fix hail damaged roofs, raise some salary levels and, most importantly, provide an ongoing source of revenue to keep our campus facilities in good repair this ballot measure easily passed. By the way, I voted for the TRE and helped promote this measure. 

While the District completed most of the year one projects outlined in the TRE literature, the most important promise of funneling TRE dollars year after year into completing the many major maintenance items our schools need got diverted to other uses. What other uses?  Despite repeatedly asking I’m not sure but I do know they never made it to the promised school maintenance. When I and other taxpayers who remember the promises made bring up this broken promise, we are routinely patted on the head like brain addled children and are told this promise was never made. 

TRUST ISSUE #2

Headlines has written extensively on the scheme hatched by ECISD’s financial planners to hijack the large tax cuts that local taxpayers should have received as a result of the Texas legislature’s work to reduce some of the highest property taxes in America. At a town hall meeting I again brought up the details of this plan to be quickly put in my place by ECISD Chief Financial Officer Debra Ottmers who pointedly stated that it up to the school district’s staff and school trustees to determine how and when bonds are repaid despite what voters may be led to believe during an election. Period. End of discussion. 

This hijacking of taxpayers’ dollars has resulted in local taxpayers paying hundreds to thousands of dollars more in taxes each year than is necessary to meet our debt obligations and these additional and unnecessary costs have been foisted on the backs of working families that were struggling through COVID and negative oil prices. 

TRUST ISSUE #3

Two very important items on the actual bond ballot should be noted. First, despite the rhetoric being used by bond proponents and the District that passing this enormous bond won’t raise your taxes the ballot says otherwise: “THIS IS A PROPERTY TAX INCREASE.”  This language is mandated by the State of Texas because it is a true and factual statement that our state wants taxpayers to know and understand. 

The second is to note that this bond, as described on the ballot, is NOT about a career and technical center, or a middle school or a bus barn or to complete a lot of deferred maintenance. According to the ballot this election is for the issuance of “$424,263,000 OF BONDS FOR SCHOOL BUILDINGS”. Legally, we have no assurance that this money will be spent exactly as promised any more than the unenforceable promises made by a school district that has already broken promises made during the TRE election and has oftentimes forced struggling taxpayers to pay higher than required taxes for years. 

Even if we were to believe that we can trust the current administration it is highly likely that before any projects are completed that the composition of the trustee board will change and/or that our current administration leaders will be different. Because of this reality we need the ballot language to legally bind our district to the projects proposed which it does not. 

I hate to be so cynical of our school district but, based on their recent history, I don’t think I can muster up enough trust to do anything but to vote against this bond and I would encourage Ector County voters to do the same. 

My Vote Against The 2023 ECISD Bond Comes Down To One Word: TRUST is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
ECISD Trustees Punt On School Safety and Security https://odessaheadlines.com/2023/08/30/ecisd-trustees-punt-on-school-safety-and-security/ Wed, 30 Aug 2023 13:22:41 +0000 https://odessaheadlines.com/?p=2232 Texas House Bill 3 makes several significant changes to school safety laws, including requiring districts to assign armed personnel at every campus. While each school board can determine the appropriate number of armed security officers for each district campus, the law mandates that at least one armed security officer – specifically a commissioned peace officer […]

ECISD Trustees Punt On School Safety and Security is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
Texas House Bill 3 makes several significant changes to school safety laws, including requiring districts to assign armed personnel at every campus. While each school board can determine the appropriate number of armed security officers for each district campus, the law mandates that at least one armed security officer – specifically a commissioned peace officer – is present during regular school hours at each campus.

School districts can, however, apply for a good cause exception due to lack of funding or qualified personnel. If the board claims an exception, the board must provide an alternative plan that may include reliance on a school marshal or an employee or contracted individual who has completed the handgun safety course required for handgun license holders and is authorized to carry a firearm by the district (often called a “guardian” or a “school marshal”). These requirements go into effect with the 2023-24 school year.

Following a short discussion during last Tuesday’s school board meeting ECISD trustees voted 7-0 to approve a resolution to submit to the State of Texas claiming a good cause exception to the HB 3 security mandates.

Trustees were provided information indicating that compliance with HB 3 would cost the district approximately $70,500 per officer per year in salary and benefits. Additionally, approximately $79,000 per officer would be required in year one to cover fully outfitting each officer including a police car. Trustees were also told that state funding would only cover $684,000 of the approximately 4.5 million dollars of year one costs.

“I’m a bit frustrated with our school trustees,” stated Ector County Republican Party Chair Tisha Crow. “While I realize that adding additional costs to our school district’s budget isn’t ideal, I think we also need our Trustees to keep this number in perspective. The costs associated with armed school personnel represents less than one half of one percent of our $410 million school budget. I think this is a small price to pay to ensure that our students, teachers, and staff are as safe as possible.  I believe that if our school administration would look closely at our budget we could save a half percent somewhere less critical in order to secure our schools. For example, I consider keeping our students, teachers and staff safe much more important than spending big bucks updating our Smartboards.  As we saw just recently at Permian High School the threats to our schools are real and they are ever present and I pray that our school trustees’ unwillingness to fund better campus security in compliance with state law doesn’t have tragic consequences.”

In order to claim a good cause exception the District must also provide an alternative plan which could include arming specially trained school staff to act in the position of “guardian”. No alternative plan was discussed at Tuesday’s Board meeting.

In an interview with Wallace Dunn, a local firearms expert and trainer, Dunn stated that over the past four years he has discussed with District staff and Trustees ways to enable the District to have highly trained armed personnel on every campus but has always been rebuffed.  “Shorty after Dr. Muri was hired I met with him and told him that I would provide – free of any cost to the District – a comprehensive two day training course that would qualify someone to be a school marshal.  I have also talked with several school board members over the past several years about providing this training as a way to beef up our school security and to protect our students.  To put it kindly, I’ve received a very cold shoulder from the District which has really frustrated me.”  

Dunn continued, “We have endured mass shootings at schools for over 30 years now. There are experts in the field that KNOW how to stop this, and the school districts choose not to use their services. The model of “call 911 and wait,” DOES NOT WORK. We must have a FASTER armed response to stop these murderers as soon as possible.  This is a hot button issue for me and I am very worried that the only way our District is going to get serious about protecting our campuses by having armed, trained personnel on every campus is after we end up with some dead students or staff.”

Odessa Headlines contacted all seven ECISD Trustees via email for their plan moving forward.  As of publication, only two Trustees – Wayne Woodall and Bob Thayer – responded to our request.  Trustee Woodall stated that he wants to meet the Texas mandate for armed personnel on every campus “as soon as possible” and stated that “I would be in favor of any help with staffing we can get. Guardians may be a solution. I would have to look into it more.”  Woodall also replied that “In the end I am very pleased that Texas has passed this law, our children deserve to be protected at all times and this may sound cliché but it is the truth the only way to stop a bad guy with  a gun is to have a good guy with a gun.”

When asked about utilizing school “Guardians” Trustee Thayer stated “I believe we will consider any and all possibilities as the Law allows. In the past, some campuses have tried to organize ‘Watch Dog’ teams. These are involved dads who help with drop off in the morning and a roaming presence throughout the day. Just having a strong presence, not necessarily an armed presence, serves as a deterrence.”  When asked how important he thought it would be to have licensed and trained law enforcement personnel on every campus Thayer responded “I believe having licensed and trained personnel on campus would make a big difference, but it isn’t the only way to create a safer environment. Guardians, Watch Dogs, volunteers in the AM and PM drop offs, etc can make a difference.”

Trustee Dawn Miller also responded to Odessa Headlines request for comment with “Thank you for your interest. Any board comments, per our Board Policy, should be directed to our board President, Chris Stanley. I’ve copied him on this email so he can correspond directly to you.”  Odessa Headlines asked Miller what Board policy she was referring to but as of publication she has not responded.

HB 3 also requires each district employee who has regular contact with students to undergo mental health first-aid training. Compliance dates for this provision are staggered, with all employees needing to be trained by 2028-29.

ECISD Trustees Punt On School Safety and Security is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
Letter To The Editor – Dallas Kennedy https://odessaheadlines.com/2023/07/26/letter-to-the-editor-dallas-kennedy/ Wed, 26 Jul 2023 20:55:21 +0000 https://odessaheadlines.com/?p=2217 Dear Editor, I attended that ECISD Board of Trustees special meeting to discuss the potential bond and wanted to give my perspective.   In full disclosure, I was on the bond committee and I am a teacher with ECISD.  I have been skeptical of past bonds, but we are at a point where we have to […]

Letter To The Editor – Dallas Kennedy is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
Dear Editor,

I attended that ECISD Board of Trustees special meeting to discuss the potential bond and wanted to give my perspective.   In full disclosure, I was on the bond committee and I am a teacher with ECISD. 

I have been skeptical of past bonds, but we are at a point where we have to do something to maintain facilities and create new opportunities for students to learn relevant skills.  

I encourage everyone to look at the ECISD Bond website to see everything proposed in the bond.  The main takeaways are that the district wants a new CTE Center, middle school, and funds to fix numerous maintenance issues.  There is also proposed funding for fine arts, special education, athletics, technology, transportation, and agriculture.

1. Our schools have major maintenance issues that have to be addressed.  This bond will address those issues.  We can argue all day about why those maintenance issues exist, but that does not change the fact that they do exist.  If we do not fix them now, we will have to replace buildings in the near future.

2.  We need to address CTE training.  I have heard many say that we have to prepare our students for the 21st century.  Well, we are already a quarter of a way through the century and still trying to teach CTE in buildings built halfway through the 20th century.  We need a space to teach our students relevant skills that they can use in an ever-changing world.  Our West Texas economy needs students with these skills.

3.  This bond proposal addresses the students that may not have been historically addressed in the past.  This bond includes money for our choirs, bands, and other fine arts programs.  When is the last time we addressed them in a meaningful way?  This bond includes money for a Transition Learning Center.  This is a center that teaches real-world life skills to students in special education.  The students learn vocational skills and daily living skills that set them up to live their most independent and successful lives.  This money includes money to fix an extremely outdated agriculture farm.  We all know that we need more students interested in farming and ranching if we want to continue to feed our population throughout the century.

3.  One argument I hear is that the public does not trust ECISD because of how past ECISD leadership handled funds and maintenance.  I too have been skeptical of past administrations, but those administrations are gone.   Attend a school board meeting.  We have three new school board members that are asking hard questions.  At the meeting last night, I saw some robust debate, which tells me that the school board members are not just rubber-stamping everything.  

4.  This is the most important takeaway for me: the school board has until Aug. 21 to decide what is in the bond.  That means if you have questions, comments, complaints or concerns NOW is the time to act.  The school board members plan on scheduling four community meetings to hear from the community before they finalize what is put in the bond.  Show up.  Speak up.  They sincerely want to hear what you have to say.  I attend a lot of meetings in town involving our local governments.  I usually know 90% of the citizens there because it is the same 5-20 people who show up.  The only way to make a difference and let your voice be heard is to share your voice.  The email addresses and phone numbers of every school board member are posted publically at https://www.ectorcountyisd.org/domain/125 .  Tell them what you think.  They really do want to know.  

Sincerely,

Dallas Kennedy
Concerned Citizen

Letter To The Editor – Dallas Kennedy is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
HEADLINES OPINION:  It’s Time For ECISD To Get Honest With Taxpayers https://odessaheadlines.com/2023/07/22/headlines-opinion-its-time-for-ecisd-to-get-honest-with-taxpayers/ Sat, 22 Jul 2023 18:24:25 +0000 https://odessaheadlines.com/?p=2213 Since the days my boys attended ECISD schools I have followed ECISD’s activities and I have tried to be involved in the education of our students.  Over the years I have served on three bond committees (including the current one), done multiple stints on the Student Health Advisory Committee (SHAC), been a part of a […]

HEADLINES OPINION:  It’s Time For ECISD To Get Honest With Taxpayers is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
Since the days my boys attended ECISD schools I have followed ECISD’s activities and I have tried to be involved in the education of our students.  Over the years I have served on three bond committees (including the current one), done multiple stints on the Student Health Advisory Committee (SHAC), been a part of a dropout prevention committee and worked on a number of campaigns of those running for ECISD Trustee.

During this time – which has spanned about 25 years – one of the key complaints I have heard voiced over and over again is that people – parents and taxpayers – don’t trust ECISD.  In fact, a survey conducted by the school district a few years ago as a part of a proposed bond issue found the lack of trust as the top issue for our school district.

Unfortunately, the trust alarm needs to again be sounded as the Trustees contemplate another bond issue.

During a recent school board meeting “The Bond Committee” presented their findings to Trustees.  The presenters consisted of two ECISD employees and one ECISD student with the two employees carrying the bulk of the message.  The presenters delivered to Trustees the “recommendations” of the bond committee.  I put this in quotes because the Bond Committee didn’t finish its work with any concrete recommendations and didn’t select any presenters to represent us, the Bond Committee.

While there was widespread agreement on three of the proposed items – an $80 million Career and Technical Center (CTE) and the completion of priority one and two maintenance projects at a cost of $120 million – the discussion on other proposed projects was prematurely terminated.  One item, a new $120 million middle school was being discussed with many – myself included – flopping back and forth between whether or not now was the time to propose a new middle school.  While both Nimitz and Wilson and Young middle schools are overcrowded, other schools like Bonham and Bowie are – based on the information provided by the District – significantly underutilized.  Also, there were opinions expressed that if a single middle school was offered then disputes over where this school would be located would likely damage the prospects of passage.

A number of smaller dollar amount projects were also being discussed with everything from band uniforms to improvements to Ratliff Stadium to a new bus barn being kicked around the room.  While many on the committee felt these were worthwhile projects to consider, an honest effort by the Committee to not only prioritize these projects but also to perhaps scale back the dollars that should be allocated to each was ongoing.  When the Committee adjourned our last meeting we were promised that a survey would be distributed to the Committee to rank these smaller projects and to assign dollar amounts to each.  Weeks went by before this survey was distributed and then only ranking – not dollar amount assignment – was included in the survey.  As this was not what was promised I refused to participate in the survey rightly believing that ECISD would use this flawed survey in its narrative of presenting the “Committee’s recommendations”.

As previously reported by Odessa Headlines, near the end of the committee meetings Superintendent Muri presented Committee members with the idea of being able to complete a $400 million bond issue with no increase in taxes.  Needless to say, this got everyone’s attention.  However, upon further investigation by Odessa Headlines it was discovered that while this was technically true it was very misleading and was only the result of the fact that for a number of years ECISD has been overcharging local taxpayers on their taxes.

While this concept is a bit confusing, consider this analogy:

Suppose you and your family are in the market for a new car and you find a nice minivan that meets your needs.  You negotiate a deal to finance your new ride for 5 years at 6% interest and begin making payments.  However, unbeknownst to you, the car dealership calculates your payment at 12% interest and overcharges you each month.  After four years of payments you receive a letter from the dealership saying “Congratulations, we have a special offer for you.  Because you have been such a loyal customer we are offering you the opportunity to purchase a new, more expensive car at the same monthly payment you’re making now!”  You excitedly drive to the dealership to shop for your new car only to discover that the only reason the dealer can make this offer is because he’s overcharged you thousands of dollars over the last four years.  

In this analogy you would no doubt feel angry and betrayed because there were some months that you struggled to make your car payment and had you not been overcharged you would have had more dollars for other necessities such as groceries, medical expenses, or insurance. You would certainly never purchase from that dealership again.

Also, because the dealer had overcharged not only you but every car buyer they dealt with, complaints would no doubt be filed with the State agency that regulates auto financing and, most likely, that dealer would have been penalized and ordered to pay back the overcharges.  

In ECISD’s case this is exactly what has happened to property owners.  During the past several legislative sessions the Texas Legislature has attempted to significantly lower property taxes realizing that many Texans struggle to pay huge property tax bills – the bulk of which go to our Texas school districts.  The Legislature has done this by “compressing” the maximum amount that local school districts can tax and by replacing the funds lost by this cap on local taxes with the same amount of state taxes which come into the state primarily from sales tax and severance (oil and gas) taxes.  However, in our case as the State Legislature has been reducing the maximum amount of maintenance and operations tax that can be charged to local property owners ECISD has been intercepting those savings and placing them in the District’s debt service fund.  The end result is that while most taxpayers across our state have seen their property taxes decrease, Ector County residents have seen them at best flatten or in most cases continue to increase year after year.

Now, just like the car salesman, ECISD is attempting to use the past years of overtaxation as a propaganda tool to entice Ector County voters into upgrading into a shiny new bond issue and then they wonder why no one trusts our school district.

So, where does that leave us?

I will be the first to admit that our school facilities need help.  Once again, despite the $20 million plus in additional taxes Ector County voters approved a few years ago in the TRE election – approximately half of which was promised to go to fix/repair/replace major maintenance items – our schools are in need of major repairs and renovations to the tune of $120 million.  

Also, I think our community recognizes the importance of training more students in skilled trades whether it be welders, nurses, house framers, or auto mechanics and therefore there seems to be widespread support for a full blown career and technical education (CTE) center.  In addition to training students, the addition of a CTE would help relieve both our high schools and middle schools by shifting students from PHS and OHS to the CTE for at least part of the day.

As a point of recommendation I would like to propose this plan to our Trustees as they meet this Monday:

  1.  Approval of a bond issue election to build a new $80 million CTE center.  This center, as outlined to the Bond Committee, would include the participation of Odessa College and UTPB and some of the costs would be borne by private donations.
  2. Approval of a $120 million bond issue election to complete priority one and two maintenance items.  At the end of this work all of our campuses would be in great shape and ready to serve students for many years to come.  Repairing existing facilities will cost a small fraction of the amount to build new facilities.  
  3. The completion of a comprehensive and ongoing maintenance plan for all facilities that, once initial repairs are completed as the result of a successful bond election, keeps our facilities in good repair without having to come to taxpayers for another large debt package in the future. 
  4. “True Up” our debt service taxes.  While it’s hard to make the calculations at this time the reality is that adjusting our debt service tax rate to where it truly should be would result in a nice tax reduction for Ector County taxpayers even with $200 million in additional debt

I am hopeful that our ECISD Trustees will get honest with taxpayers about the past years of overcharging and will act with more integrity in the future by avoiding such schemes and scams.   I would encourage everyone to attend Monday night’s meeting at 6:00 PM at the ECISD Administration building and let our Trustees know where you stand.

HEADLINES OPINION:  It’s Time For ECISD To Get Honest With Taxpayers is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
ECISD Picks Taxpayer’s Pockets https://odessaheadlines.com/2023/06/19/ecisd-picks-taxpayers-pockets/ Mon, 19 Jun 2023 22:46:03 +0000 https://odessaheadlines.com/?p=2192 At Tuesday night’s Ector County ISD (ECISD) board meeting Board Members were presented with a report from the recently completed School Bond Committee as well as an hour-long presentation on the $420,359,129 2023-24 proposed school budget. During the presentations it was noted by the presenters that the bond committee felt it important, in offering a […]

ECISD Picks Taxpayer’s Pockets is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
At Tuesday night’s Ector County ISD (ECISD) board meeting Board Members were presented with a report from the recently completed School Bond Committee as well as an hour-long presentation on the $420,359,129 2023-24 proposed school budget.

During the presentations it was noted by the presenters that the bond committee felt it important, in offering a bond to the voters, that the District stay below an approximate $400 million price tag as the District had this much in available “bond capacity”.  According to the District, at current tax rates ECISD could issue up to $400 million in new debt without having to increase property owner’s tax rates to repay the bonds.

During the budget presentation which followed it became clear that the “bond capacity” being touted by ECISD amounts to nothing less than a funding scheme that is the result of years of overbilling of property taxes by the school district.

School taxes, unlike other governmental entities, have two components:  first is the maintenance and operations (M&O) part and secondly the interest and sinking (I&S) part.  M&O is used to pay for all of the operations of the District such as salaries, utilities, transportation and maintenance.  I&S, under state law, can only be used to pay for the costs associated with servicing the District’s debt.  I&S is like a homeowner’s monthly mortgage bill while M&O is everything else.

In recent years the Texas State Legislature has been very concerned about the ever growing M&O costs being shouldered by local taxpayers and began a system of providing more and more state dollars to school districts through a system called “compression”.  Basically, the State’s idea was to shift surplus state tax dollars to the school districts in exchange for the districts being capped at the maximum amount they can charge taxpayers in local M&O taxes.

Local voters will recall that in 2018, Ector County voters voluntarily raised M&O rates for county taxpayers by $0.13 per $100 of property value through a tax ratification election or TRE.  In 2018 when the TRE was approved the maximum state allowed M&O rate increased from $1.04 per $100 to $1.17 per $100.  The TRE election resulted in a 12.5% increase in local M&O taxes or approximately $18,000,000.

Since 2018, as the State has steadily increased the state funding to school districts this rate has been lowered or “compressed” to a maximum rate of $0.9235 per $100 valuation in an effort to provide property tax relief to local taxpayers.  This compression should have resulted in significant tax savings of over 21% to local property owners.

For example, for a homeowner with a taxable value on their home of $250,000 the reduction in school taxes from 2018 to 2023 should have resulted in a yearly savings of $616.25.  

For ECISD taxpayers, however, the savings that state tax compression was designed to provide never materialized and local taxpayers have continued to pay high school taxes.  Instead of providing the property tax relief planned by the Texas Legislature, ECISD simply shifted any compression savings across the ledger to the I&S column thus keeping the total local ECISD tax rate at $1.17792 and providing local property owners no relief on their high tax payments.

During Tuesday’s bond and budget presentation, Superintendent Muri, Chief Financial Officer Debra Ottmers and various members of the ECISD Board of Trustees lauded their financial stewardship and oversight in keeping taxpayer’s tax rate flat instead of providing the reduced taxes intended by the state legislature.  Ottmers stated that, instead of homeowner’s receiving a tax reduction, that homeowners like to see their expenses held at a flat level and that is what ECISD had done.

“The Texas Legislature has worked hard over the past several sessions to lower Texan’s property tax bills and it’s really frustrating to see Dr. Muri and the ECISD Trustees take such a blatant end run around our elected legislators.  For ECISD to be raking in ever increasing state dollars but refusing to pass along a rate cut to local taxpayers as intended is really disappointing.” stated Ector County Republican Party Chair Tisha Crow.  “On top of that, to ask us to applaud their overtaxation of the hard working taxpayers in Ector County and to try to dress up their overtaxation as anything other than a dirty trick to get a bond passed is really incredible.”

Based on an analysis of the compressed tax rate versus the tax rate actually levied by Muri and the ECISD School Trustees, Odessa Headlines calculated the overcharge amounts for Ector County property owners based on the taxable value of their home or business.

“For local taxpayers to have had thousands of dollars pulled from their pocket as a result of the District’s creative accounting really angers me” stated Crow.  “Remember, this is in the middle of COVID and the big reductions many people saw in their income.  The school board seems to have forgotten that because of the Biden created inflation many people are struggling to make ends meet.  These overcharges represent money that I know many taxpayers need to make car payments, house payments, or to buy school clothes and supplies.  Because of being overcharged on their taxes, families have had to do without many necessities and Dr. Muri and his staff seem to be just fine with that but I’m not.  I am confident that Ector County residents are going to be furious when they realize how ECISD has picked the taxpayer’s pocket.”

The ECISD 2023/24 tax rate will be up for discussion again at tomorrow night’s school board meeting and local residents are encouraged to attend.  The meeting will be held at 6:00 PM at ECISD headquarters at 802 N. Sam Houston.

ECISD Picks Taxpayer’s Pockets is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
ECISD Bond Committee Work Far From Complete https://odessaheadlines.com/2023/05/15/ecisd-bond-committee-work-far-from-complete/ Mon, 15 May 2023 15:49:25 +0000 https://odessaheadlines.com/?p=2178 The current ECISD Bond Committee is the third bond committee on which I’ve served. In 2017 I was a part of the committee that brought forth the $291 million bond proposal that was rejected by voters 62% to 38%. In committee (and at the ballot box) I voted against this proposal. The 2017 bond would […]

ECISD Bond Committee Work Far From Complete is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
The current ECISD Bond Committee is the third bond committee on which I’ve served. In 2017 I was a part of the committee that brought forth the $291 million bond proposal that was rejected by voters 62% to 38%. In committee (and at the ballot box) I voted against this proposal. The 2017 bond would have built a new high school, converted Ector back to a high school, built a new middle school, spent $27 million on technology upgrades and completed around $30 million in improvements to a number of campuses.

In 2018, I again served on a bond committee that morphed into the TRE committee. The plan brought forward from this committee was a proposal to voters to voluntarily increase our state mandated maximum tax rate for maintenance and operations from $1.04 to $1.17. It is important to note that this tax increase – which yielded over $18 million in additional revenue in year one – was not a one year increase but a permanent increase in taxes that continues year after year. It’s also important to note that, as property values have risen sharply in the years since the TRE was passed, the revenue brought in by this tax increase has also increased.

The promises made by the school district during the TRE election was that roughly half of the extra TRE revenue would be used to support staff raises (ongoing), to purchase new buses (ongoing), and pay the insurance deductibles left over from the hail storm (a one time amount of approximately $9 million). Because this tax increase was permanent there was also an understanding that the TRE would continue to support staff salaries AND provide the ongoing funding we needed for bus replacements and major maintenance needs to keep our facilities in good condition.

I was asked to be on the 2022 Bond Committee but declined. This almost $400 million plan was defeated by roughly 60% of Ector County voters.

Now, we come to the current 2023 Bond Committee. This committee began with around 140 members and, as with most committees, has steadily shrunk in active participation over the course of the seven meetings. Our final meeting was held last Thursday, May 4, 2023 when it was declared and reported that our work was done.

As a committee member I would dispute that our work is anywhere near complete.

At the start of every meeting, we were presented with a review of the Committee’s mandate:

  1. Receive and review the findings of an updated, Facilities Assessment regarding physical condition and other aspects of all District facilities.
    The Committee did receive a very exhaustive facilities assessment but spent almost no time reviewing its contents. It did appear that the assessment provided was somewhat out of date. At no time did we discuss what specific, big ticket maintenance items would cost nor how/who derived those costs – we were simply presented with some very large maintenance costs for priority 1 ($51 million) and priority 2 ($79 million) maintenance needs. If I were to assign a grade based on the completeness of the work done on this item I would give it a “C-“.
  2. Receive and review the findings of a 2022 Demographic Study of the Ector County ISD.
    The demographic study used in support of the 2022 failed bond his study showed steady growth in student numbers for the next ten years. This study, the District said, clearly showed the need for additional facilities to house an ever growing student population. “Trust the data” we were told – our schools are going to keep growing.

    The update to the 2022 study was again compiled by Davis Demographics but showed a radically different picture. In the 2023 update Davis Demographics projected a DECLINING student population.

In this graph, the dark grey bars in the background are the projections made for the 2022 bond and the colored bars are the new “post COVID” projections that show a gradually declining student population. I can’t say that I have much confidence in Davis Demographic’s work but we do know that our school population has dropped significantly from our pre COVID high of 33,363. This time the bond committee was told “don’t trust the data – no way it can be correct”.

Even after Davis made some revisions to their analysis I don’t believe anyone has much confidence in their work and I would rate this item a “F”.

3. Review options for existing, renovated, and/or new facilities, and their
implications for projected student enrollment, anticipated instructional
programs/technology, and related educational specifications, district staff,
operations, and costs.


Here are some numbers that truly shocked me:
There are 5,421 empty and available Elementary school seats NOT INCLUDING portables. Add portables and our District has over 6,817 empty and available Elementary school seats.

ECISD currently has a number of elementary campuses that are below 60% capacity: Alamo (55%), Burnet (47%), Dowling (54%), Travis (40%), and Zavala (46%). There are also another batch that are under 75% utilized. Please note: these capacity numbers do NOT include any of the dreaded portable buildings that seem to become a part of every bond election’s marketing.

Likewise, while some middle schools are full – Nimitz is at 96% capacity when including a healthy number of portables while Wilson & Young is at 99% capacity – Bowie, has 341 available permanent seats available and Bonham has 106 permanent seats and a total of 281 seats available if portables are included.

It is true that some schools in our District are bulging but it’s also true that others are starving for students. The reason is that our school boundaries are in serious need of updating but the Committee wasn’t able to talk about this because of #3 on the “What Not To Do List” shown above. I understand that it is the Trustee’s job to determine actual school boundaries but to prohibit the Bond Committee from discussion about the impact that improperly drawn boundaries are having on our students is, quite simply put, ridiculous.

As for Item #3 in our mandate I don’t believe that the Committee was allowed time to discuss and evaluate most of these items:

  • Beyond the really huge maintenance dollar amounts thrown at us we did not discuss options for the existing facilities nor exactly what the proposed renovations would include or not include. We certainly didn’t spend time discussing what these renovations/additions would accomplish beyond the most cursory analysis.
  • When it comes to the “anticipated instructional programs/technology, and related educational specifications” we didn’t do any work here. While the Committee seemed to be unified in building a new CTE center we had to literally pull nuggets of information from District staff as to what programs would be offered at a new CTE center, how many students it might serve, etc. etc. Even then, the information we were provided was scant and without detail or specificity.
  • Beyond some passing questions of “how will we staff new schools” the Committee never got to look at the implications of additional facilities on “district staff, operations, and costs”. The reality is that, as long as I can remember, we’ve never had a school board that ensured that we could keep our existing facilities in good condition as is evidenced by the huge price tag assigned to priority one and priority two maintenance needs. It’s only common sense that if we build additional facilities that these facilities must then be operated and maintained. The Committee should have had an opportunity to consider the implications on costs any recommendations brought forward might entail.

Sadly, I would have to give a grade of “D” to the Committee on mandate #3. This grade isn’t reflective of the work the Committee has done – it simply reflects the fact that we had inadequate time to consider these objectives.

4. Develop and present to the Board of Trustees a Bond Plan to serve the district as a baseline for the next 5 years and future facility needs.
Currently, we have no plan to present. Our work was declared finished and the Committee is charged with presenting a plan to the Trustees but we don’t have a plan. An outline of a plan has barely been completed. We have no one to present a plan to the Trustees as the Committee hasn’t been allowed to select members to represent the Committee as a whole.

The grade for item #4? Incomplete.

The bottom line? The Committee’s work is unfinished and needs more time to develop a fully baked plan that we can all be proud of and support. We need a plan that utilizes every single District resource to the fullest and protects the taxpayer’s pocket.

In a future post I’ll detail what is being proposed and will do my best to relay to the community the good and bad of whatever plan the District moves forward. Our District has some real needs and we are going to have spend some money but if we want voters to approve a big spending plan we must lay out a well thought out and complete plan.

On a personal note, I appreciate the time spent by everyone who served alongside me on the Bond Committee. I especially appreciate the members of the public – moms and dads and others concerned about our students – who showed up meeting after meeting. I especially appreciate David Munger, a District employee at OHS, who served with me on other bond committees but was exiled to a back table and blocked from participating in our discussions despite my table’s repeated attempts to have him included. David has a real heart for our students and I would have liked to seen him included.

ECISD Bond Committee Work Far From Complete is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
Ethical Leadership Missing From OEL Candidate Forum https://odessaheadlines.com/2023/04/21/ethical-leadership-missing-from-oel-candidate-forum/ Fri, 21 Apr 2023 22:27:29 +0000 https://odessaheadlines.com/?p=2149 Thursday night, Odessans For Ethical Leadership (OEL) hosted a forum at the Odessa College Saulsbury room for Ector County Independent School District (ECISD) candidates for the upcoming May 6th, 2023 election. The forum was hosted by OEL and was led by Angie Hurt King and was moderated by KOSA reporter Mary Kate Hamilton. Hamilton worked […]

Ethical Leadership Missing From OEL Candidate Forum is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
Thursday night, Odessans For Ethical Leadership (OEL) hosted a forum at the Odessa College Saulsbury room for Ector County Independent School District (ECISD) candidates for the upcoming May 6th, 2023 election.

The forum was hosted by OEL and was led by Angie Hurt King and was moderated by KOSA reporter Mary Kate Hamilton. Hamilton worked off a list of prepared questions and then those in attendance provided additional questions which were fielded by the candidates toward the end of the forum.

Five candidates – incumbents Donna Smith and Dennis Jones, and challengers Wayne Woodall, Bob Thayer, and John Rabenaldt – fielded questions in round robin style during the first hour of the forum and presented a variety of positions on everything from school choice to overcrowding and school finance.

Early in the forum, during a question regarding problems within ECISD, candidate Smith stated that she was going to touch on subject of bullying despite the fact “I think we are going to get a question on bullying in just a little while”.

Smith’s comment indicated that candidates had received the questions before the forum – which would be unusual for a candidate forum where protocol typically calls for the candidates to be given each question “live” and at the same time. Most voters can recall the furor sparked when Democratic National Committee Chair Donna Brazile leaked CNN’s debate questions to Hillary Clinton ahead of a presidential candidate debate.

After the forum, Odessa Headlines asked Smith if she had received the forum questions ahead of time and she readily admitted that she had and that it “was helpful to know the questions when you only have 90 seconds to respond.”

Odessa Headlines contacted candidates Woodall, Thayer, and Jones (despite our efforts, we were unable to contact Rabenaldt) and enquired if they had received the questions ahead of the forum and all stated they had no advance information on the questions.

Early Friday morning Odessa Headlines reached out to Angie Hurt King who organized the forum for comment specifically asking whether or not any candidates were provided advance copies of the forum questions but King has not responded. Odessa Headlines also sought further comment and clarification from Smith as to how she obtained access to the questions and whether or not she knew she was the lone candidate with prior access but Smith did not respond to our request.

“If one candidate was provided the questions ahead of time and the others weren’t this really gives that one candidate an advantage. I don’t think that’s fair and it certainly isn’t ethical.” stated attendee Ned Luscombe. “For an organization with the word ethical in their name, this type of behavior doesn’t seem very ethical.”

Early voting starts Monday, April 24 and Election Day is Saturday, May 7th.

Ethical Leadership Missing From OEL Candidate Forum is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
ECISD Priorities At Odds With Local Voters https://odessaheadlines.com/2023/01/19/ecisd-priorities-at-odds-with-local-voters/ Thu, 19 Jan 2023 21:50:31 +0000 https://odessaheadlines.com/?p=1958 With the opening of Texas’ 2023 legislative session earlier this month, the legislative priorities unanimously passed by the Ector County ISD Board of Trustees last year are receiving renewed scrutiny. As recently reported in statewide and nationwide media the controversy centers on the District’s positions on school choice and bringing back Chapter 313 tax breaks. […]

ECISD Priorities At Odds With Local Voters is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>
With the opening of Texas’ 2023 legislative session earlier this month, the legislative priorities unanimously passed by the Ector County ISD Board of Trustees last year are receiving renewed scrutiny. As recently reported in statewide and nationwide media the controversy centers on the District’s positions on school choice and bringing back Chapter 313 tax breaks.

According to a document released by the district, the official position of Ector County ISD is to “oppose the development of voucher programs” and to further “limit charter expansion and move the charter approval process to local school boards.” Speaking during the October 18th meeting of the Ector County ISD Board of Trustees, Trustee Delma Abalos defended her opposition to vouchers by stating that “everybody that supports public education really needs to speak out against any attempt to take money away from us.” This position, however, pits the board against growing support for vouchers. As reported, Governor Greg Abbott voiced support for the program last year, stating that the program gives parents “the choice to send their children to any public school, charter school or private school with state funding following the student.”

Governor Abbott’s support for so called “voucher” programs squares with Ector County voters who, when asked about “Proposition 9” in the March 2022 Republican primary election voted over 91% in favor of the proposition which read “Texas parents and guardians should have the right to select schools, whether public or private, for their children, and the funding should follow the student.”  

“It is very frustrating and disturbing when elected officials are so clearly opposed to the wishes of the voters who they were elected to represent.” said Ector County Republican Party Chair Tisha Crow when asked about the District’s stated priorities.  “It seems that our current school trustees are more interested in maintaining the status quo of long running failures in publicly managed schools rather than to strive to improve as they compete against other schools.  We all know that competition raises the bar for everyone and ECISD’s stand against both charter schools and the school funding options that voters want clearly shows that ECISD needs new leadership on our Board”.

The district also officially supports reinstatement of the Chapter 313 tax break program, which expired at the end of last year. The district claims that “school districts benefited from these agreements as they improved the local economy.” However, not everyone is sold on the idea. According to a study by Dr. Nathan Jenson, about “85-90% of projects would have located in Texas without the 313 program.” Meanwhile, some other opponents of the program argued that it amounted to governments interfering in the market by picking winners and losers.  Other opponents of 313 agreements have posited that while 313 agreements provide a short term boost to school coffers that long term these agreements steal away millions of dollars in school funding as they exempt huge amounts of potential tax dollars due to the abatements offered by local governments.  

Unlike the district’s position regarding school choice, it does appear there is strong support for the district’s position on Chapter 313 among state leaders. In particular, Dade Phelan, who won reelection as the speaker of the state house, has voiced support for bringing the program back.

Several places on the Ector County ISD Board of Trustees will be on the ballot on May 6th. Place 1, 3, and 6 are up for four-year terms, while Place 7 is up for the remaining 2 years of an unexpired term. Filing for candidates opens on January 18th and ends February 17th.

ECISD Priorities At Odds With Local Voters is a story from Odessa Headlines, a publication covering Ector County, Texas. Odessa Headlines’ vision is to provide quality in-depth original coverage and commentary of local issues – predominantly politics and public policy – while cross-sharing excellent coverage of state and national issues from our media partners across Texas.

]]>